Customs House Agents licence renewal norms: refusal was justified after the licensee failed to meet prescribed requirements.

Customs House Agents licence renewal may be refused where the licensing authority is empowered to prescribe renewal norms and the licensee fails to meet them even after an additional opportunity. The Tribunal found that the appellant had already received an ex gratia renewal and further chance, yet did not satisfy the parameters in the public notice. On those facts, a further indulgence was not warranted, and the cited precedent was distinguished as turning on different circumstances. Refusal to renew the licence was therefore justified and the challenge failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the denial of renewal of the Customs House Agents licence for failure to satisfy the prescribed renewal norms was justified.

Analysis: Regulation 12(2)(a) of the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulation, 1984 empowers the Commissioner to prescribe norms for renewal of a CHA licence. The appellant had been given an ex gratia renewal and further opportunity, but still did not satisfy any of the parameters laid down in the Public Notice. The Tribunal held that the plea for another chance was not sustainable, as the earlier renewal had not resulted in any improvement and the facts were distinguishable from the cited precedent supporting indulgence.

Conclusion: The denial of renewal was upheld and the appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the licensing authority is empowered to prescribe renewal norms and the licensee fails to satisfy those norms even after an additional opportunity, refusal to renew the licence is justified.

---