Marketability and essential character guided classification of Crayplas Compound as crayons rather than pigments.

Crayplas Compound was treated as excisable goods because it had already been recognised in the assessee's own case as a marketable product emerging in the manufacture of plastic crayons. On classification, the product was held to be closer to finished crayons than to pigments and preparations based thereon, so Heading 96.09 was accepted in preference to Heading 32.04. The earlier finding on the same product was followed, and the broader competing heading was rejected. The result was classification under CETA sub-heading 9609.00 rather than 3204.10, with no duty liability for the period in dispute.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether Crayplas Compound was excisable goods; (ii) under which CETA sub-heading the product was classifiable.

Issue (i): Whether Crayplas Compound was excisable goods.

Analysis: The product had already been held in the assessee's own case to be a marketable commodity emerging in the course of manufacture of plastic crayons. That finding was treated as governing the dispute, and the challenge to excisability was not accepted.

Conclusion: The product was held to be excisable goods.

Issue (ii): Under which CETA sub-heading the product was classifiable.

Analysis: The earlier decision on the same product had settled classification by holding that Crayplas shapeless plastic crayons had the essential characteristics of finished crayons and were more akin to crayons than to pigments and preparations based thereon. On that basis, classification under Heading 96.09 was accepted in preference to Heading 32.04.

Conclusion: The goods were held classifiable under CETA sub-heading 9609.00 and not under CETA sub-heading 3204.10.

Final Conclusion: The impugned classification under Heading 32.04 was set aside and the product was brought under Heading 96.09, resulting in no duty liability for the period in dispute.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a manufactured product is marketable and possesses the essential characteristics of the finished article, classification follows the article to which it is more closely akin rather than the broader competing heading.

---