Carbon-black classification under Heading 40.05 determined free importability and defeated the licence-based confiscation claim.

Imported self-amalgamating tapes and semi-conducting tapes were treated as classifiable under Heading 40.05 sub-heading 4005.10 where supplier literature described them as covered with carbon black and adhesive in nature. That specific entry was preferred over sub-heading 4005.91, which covers other plates, sheets and strips, and the Revenue failed to displace the carbon-black description with chemical test or expert evidence. On that basis, the goods were regarded as freely importable without a licence, and the classification approach adopted by the appellate authority was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported self-amalgamating tapes and semi-conducting tapes were classifiable under chapter sub-heading 4005.10 as goods compounded with carbon black, or under sub-heading 4005.91 as plates, sheets and strips, and whether they were therefore freely importable without a licence.

Analysis: The decisive question was the proper tariff classification under Heading 40.05. The goods were described in the supplier's literature as being covered with carbon black and adhesive in nature. On that footing, sub-heading 4005.10, which covers goods compounded with carbon black or silicon, was the specific entry applicable. The Revenue did not establish, by chemical test or expert opinion, that the imported goods were not compounded with carbon black. Sub-heading 4005.91 was treated as covering the other plates, sheets and strips, namely goods other than those specifically covered by 4005.10. Once the goods fell under 4005.10, they were freely importable and no import licence was required.

Conclusion: The goods were correctly classifiable under sub-heading 4005.10 and were freely importable. The Revenue's objection to classification failed, and the confiscation and penalty based on want of licence could not stand.

Final Conclusion: The classification adopted by the Commissioner (Appeals) was upheld, with the result that the Revenue's challenge to the importability of the goods was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: Where imported goods are shown to be compounded with carbon black, they fall under the specific tariff entry for such goods, and the Revenue must displace that claim with reliable evidence before invoking a different residual classification.

---