Physician's sample valuation and limitation led to partial pre-deposit waiver, with balance duty and penalties stayed.

Valuation of physician's samples under the excise valuation rules was examined in the context of waiver of pre-deposit. Because the appellant had repeatedly filed declarations showing cost-construction plus profit valuation, supported by Chartered Accountant's certificates, a prima facie case was found for the period up to July 1999 and the demand for that period was treated as prima facie time-barred. For the later period from July 1999 to May 2000, no prima facie case for complete waiver was made out. Partial waiver was therefore granted, subject to a deposit of Rs. 15 lakhs, with the balance duty and penalties stayed pending appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant had made out a prima facie case for waiver of pre-deposit of the duty demand and penalties, and whether the demand for the earlier period was prima facie barred by limitation.

Analysis: The demand related to valuation of physician's samples under the excise valuation rules. The record showed that the appellant had been filing declarations from time to time giving details of valuation on a cost construction plus profit basis and that such declarations were supported by Chartered Accountant's certificates. On that basis, a prima facie case was found for the period up to July 1999, and the demand for that period was treated as prima facie time-barred. For the later period from July 1999 to May 2000, no prima facie case for complete waiver was made out.

Conclusion: The appellant was granted partial waiver of pre-deposit. A deposit of Rs. 15 lakhs was directed, and on such deposit, the balance duty and penalties were stayed pending the appeals.

---