Customs House Agent licence suspension held unjustified where alleged certificate misuse was not sufficiently established

Suspension of a Customs House Agent licence was found unwarranted where the alleged misuse of a Public Health Officer certificate was not sufficiently established on the material before the Tribunal. The Tribunal noted that only a xerox copy of an earlier certificate used for clearance of a previous consignment of the same importer had been relied on, that the goods had been allowed to be re-exported, and that no action had been taken against the importer. On those facts, it concluded that the extreme measure of suspension could not be justified and set aside the suspension order.

---

---

Issues: Whether suspension of the Customs House Agent licence was justified under Regulation 21(2) of the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations, 1984 on the facts of the case.

Analysis: The licence was suspended on the basis of alleged misuse of a Public Health Officer certificate. The Tribunal noted that, on the material placed, only a xerox copy of the earlier certificate used for clearing a previous consignment of the same importer had been used for the present clearance. It also noted that the goods had been permitted to be re-exported, no action had been taken against the importer, and the appellant had been deprived of its livelihood without a sufficient basis for such an extreme measure.

Conclusion: The suspension was not justified and the order suspending the CHA licence was set aside in favour of the appellant.

Final Conclusion: The Tribunal held that the facts did not warrant suspension of the CHA licence and restored the appellant's position by setting aside the impugned suspension order.

---