Royalty and technical know-how payments affect customs value only when they condition the sale and influence import price.

Royalty and lump sum technical know-how payments are added to the assessable value of imported goods only where the evidence shows they were a condition of sale, influenced the transaction price, and were connected with the imported goods under the valuation rule. A mere commercial or contractual relationship between importer and supplier is not enough. On the facts, the imports were made at international price list values, the royalty was calculated on net selling price after exclusions, and there was no proof that the importer had to source the spares only from the collaborator or that the payments related to the imported spares in the required manner. The assessable value therefore could not be enhanced.

---

---

Issues: Whether royalty and lump sum fees were required to be added to the assessable value of imported spares under the valuation rules.

Analysis: Addition to assessable value requires evidence that the payment was a condition of sale, that the relationship between the importer and supplier influenced the transaction value, and that the expenditure was connected with the imported goods in a manner contemplated by the valuation rule. Mere reliance on legal provisions is insufficient unless the facts establish their applicability. On the record, the imports were at international price list values, the royalty was computed on net selling price after excluding bought-out components, taxes and forwarding expenses, and there was no evidence showing that the respondents were bound to source the spares only from the collaborator or that the royalty related to the imported spares in the manner alleged.

Conclusion: The departmental appeal failed, and no interference with the order-in-original was warranted.

Final Conclusion: The assessable value could not be enhanced on the basis of the alleged royalty and lump sum fee payments, and the impugned order was sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: Inclusion of royalty or technical know-how payments in assessable value requires proof that the payment was a condition of sale and that it actually influenced the import price; a mere contractual or commercial relationship is insufficient.

---