Printed computer stationery, not self-copying paper, where customer-specific matter is printed before partial coating in a continuous process.

Paper first printed with customer-specific names, logos and particulars and then only partially coated in a continuous process was held not to be self-copying paper under Heading 48.16. The product acquired its essential character as printed computer stationery, with perforation, punching and fan-folding only completing the stationery form. Supporting technical opinion and the absence of any contrary expert evidence reinforced classification as printed matter under sub-heading 4901.90. Because the goods were not marketable as self-copying paper in their intermediate form, the demand based on Heading 48.16 could not stand.

---

---

Issues: Whether the product emerging after printing and partial coating in a continuous manufacturing process was classifiable as self-copying paper under Heading 48.16, or as printed computer stationery under sub-heading 4901.90.

Analysis: The manufacturing sequence showed that the paper was first printed with customer-specific names, logos and details and was then coated only at selected places to develop the copying character, followed by perforation, punching and fan-folding. The product was therefore not plain self-copying paper but printed stationery produced online in a continuous process. The Board's circular on printed forms and tickets supported classification of printed matter requiring only minor filling-up under sub-heading 4901.90. The expert opinion from the Institute of Paper Technology also distinguished the product from self-copy paper, and no contrary technical opinion was produced by the Revenue. The fact that the goods were not marketable as self-copying paper in the intermediate form further supported the assessee's stand.

Conclusion: The product was not classifiable under Heading 48.16 as carbonless or self-copying paper. It was correctly treated as printed computer stationery falling outside that heading, and the demand based on the contrary classification could not stand.

Ratio Decidendi: Where paper is first printed with customer-specific matter and then only partially coated in a continuous process, it is not self-copying paper under Heading 48.16 but printed stationery to be classified according to its essential character as printed matter.

---