The Four Pillars of Indirect Taxation.

The Four Pillars of Indirect Taxation, namely Classification, Declaration, Valuation, and Exemption & Concession, are foundational concepts that play a critical role in both Customs and GST systems. These principles ensure proper tax administration, compliance, and fair taxation. Lets break down each of these pillars in the context of Customs and GST.

1. Classification

Customs:

• Customs Classification refers to the systematic categorization of goods for the purpose of imposing the correct tariff rates. Goods are classified under the Harmonized System of Nomenclature (HSN), which is an internationally accepted method of classifying products.
• HS Code: Goods are assigned a specific HS code (6-digit code), and this classification helps determine the applicable customs duties and other related taxes. Each country may further extend this classification system (India uses an 8-digit code under the Indian Customs Tariff Act).
• Correct Classification is essential because:
  • It determines the rate of Customs Duty.
  • It helps in understanding whether any exemptions or concessions apply.
  • It aids in regulatory compliance (e.g., compliance with import/export control regulations).

GST:

• GST Classification involves categorizing goods and services under different GST Tax Slabs (0%, 5%, 12%, 18%, 28%). This classification determines the rate of tax applicable to each item.
• HSN Code for Goods: Under GST, HSN codes are used for the classification of goods. Businesses are required to declare HSN codes for their products, and the tax rate is determined based on the classification.
• SAC Code for Services: Similarly, services are classified under Services Accounting Codes (SAC), and the applicable tax rate is determined accordingly.
• Correct classification ensures proper compliance with GST tax rates and avoids underpayment or overpayment of taxes.

2. Declaration

Customs:

• Declaration in Customs is a critical step in the import and export process. The declaration involves submitting the required documents, like a Bill of Entry (for imports) or Shipping Bill (for exports), to the Customs authorities for clearance.
• The declaration includes:
  • Details of the goods (description, quantity, value, and classification).
  • The nature of the transaction (e.g., commercial or non-commercial).
  • Origin of goods, and any other necessary details.
• Accuracy of Declaration is essential because incorrect declarations can lead to penalties, seizure of goods, or even legal action.

GST:

• GST Declaration refers to the reporting of sales and purchases, along with applicable GST, in periodic returns such as GSTR-1 (for outward supplies) and GSTR-3B (for summary returns).
• Self-Assessment: Under GST, businesses must self-assess and declare their GST liability accurately. This includes:
  • The GSTIN (GST Identification Number) of the business.
  • Details of the tax charged on sales (output tax) and tax paid on purchases (input tax).
  • Filing returns within the prescribed deadlines is mandatory.
• Declaration also involves ensuring that the Input Tax Credit (ITC) is claimed correctly based on the goods or services used for business purposes.

3. Valuation

Customs:

• Customs Valuation refers to the process of determining the transaction value of imported goods for the purpose of levying customs duty. The Customs Valuation Rules (under the WTO’s Agreement on Customs Valuation) provide the framework for determining the value of goods.
  • The transaction value is generally the price actually paid or payable for the goods.
  • Additional costs such as freight, insurance, handling charges, and any other payments made to bring the goods to the point of importation are added to the transaction value to arrive at the Customs Value.
  • Methods of Valuation: If the transaction value cannot be determined, other methods such as the deductive method, computed method, and residual method are used.

GST:

• GST Valuation pertains to the determination of the value of taxable goods and services for the purpose of applying the appropriate GST rate. Under GST, the transaction value is the most commonly used method for valuation.
  • The transaction value is the price paid or payable for the supply of goods or services.
  • For goods, additional costs like packing, freight, and insurance are added to the price.
  • For services, any additional charges over and above the basic price are included in the valuation.
  • Special Valuation Provisions: There are specific provisions for related-party transactions, discounts, and composite contracts, where the valuation rules may differ.

4. Exemption and Concession

Customs:

• Exemptions in Customs allow certain goods to be imported without paying the usual customs duties, often for reasons of public policy or trade facilitation. These exemptions could include:
  • Exemption for Specific Goods: For example, raw materials used in manufacturing, or goods imported for charitable purposes, might be exempt from customs duty.
  • Duty Exemption Schemes: India has schemes like the Duty Drawback Scheme, Export Promotion Schemes, and Special Economic Zones (SEZs) where customs duties may be refunded or reduced to promote export activities or manufacturing.
  • Concessions: Customs concessions are usually provided for specific categories of goods, such as capital goods or goods imported under Free Trade Agreements (FTAs), where preferential rates are applicable.

GST:

• Exemptions in GST refer to specific goods and services that are not subject to GST. For example:
  • Essential goods (e.g., food items, healthcare services, and education services) are often exempt from GST.
  • Small businesses with annual turnover below the prescribed limit may also be exempt or allowed to pay tax under a composition scheme with a lower tax rate.
• Concessions: Certain industries or sectors may be eligible for GST concessions to reduce their tax burden. For example:
  • Zero-rated Supply: Exports are considered zero-rated, meaning they are taxed at 0%, and businesses can claim the input tax credit for export-related inputs.
  • Reduced Rates: Some essential goods and services may be taxed at lower rates, such as 5% compared to standard rates like 18%.

Summary:

• Classification: The process of categorizing goods and services to determine the applicable tax rate or duty. In Customs, this involves HS codes, while in GST, it involves GST tax slabs and HSN/SAC codes.
• Declaration: The accurate reporting of transactions, including the declaration of goods, services, and taxes. Customs requires declarations for import/export clearance, while GST requires businesses to declare their sales, purchases, and tax liabilities.
• Valuation: The process of determining the value of goods and services on which taxes or duties are imposed. Customs uses transaction value and additional costs, while GST similarly uses transaction value, adding various costs where applicable.
• Exemption and Concession: Certain goods or services are either exempted from taxes or are subject to reduced rates or special schemes to promote trade or industry. Customs exemptions and concessions are based on trade policy, while GST exemptions are often based on the nature of the goods or services.

These pillars ensure that indirect taxes are imposed and collected efficiently, fairly, and in line with both domestic and international trade regulations.

***