TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
Disputes in International Trade in context with Indian Foreign Trade (Import–Export) .
Excellent and very relevant question — especially with global supply chains and increasing cross-border trade by Indian importers and exporters.
Let’s break it down step-by-step, covering why disputes arise, available mechanisms, and practical guidance for Indian traders to resolve them effectively.
1. Nature of Disputes
Common types of disputes between importers and exporters include:
- Quality or quantity issues: Goods not matching specifications or samples.
- Delay in shipment or delivery.
- Non-payment or delayed payment.
- Breach of contract terms (Incoterms, delivery, insurance, etc.).
- Customs or regulatory compliance issues.
- Currency exchange or bank-related problems (LC discrepancies, etc.).
2. Preventive Measures (Before Disputes Arise)
Indian traders should preempt disputes through robust contracts and documentation:
Key Contractual Safeguards
- Clear Contract: Include all terms – product specifications, price, delivery schedule, payment terms, Incoterms (like FOB, CIF), and force majeure clause.
- Jurisdiction & Governing Law: Clearly mention which country’s laws apply and where disputes will be resolved (e.g., “This Agreement shall be governed by Indian law and disputes shall be settled by arbitration in Mumbai.”).
- Arbitration Clause: Always include one, even for small contracts.
- Documentation: Maintain all correspondence, inspection certificates, shipping documents, and bank transactions.
- Insurance: Marine and trade credit insurance help recover losses.
3. Dispute Resolution Mechanisms
A. Negotiation & Mediation
- The first step should always be direct communication.
- Mediation through trade bodies (like FIEO, EEPC, or local Chambers of Commerce) is low-cost and preserves relationships.
- International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) and Indian Council of Arbitration (ICA) offer conciliation services.
B. Arbitration (Preferred in International Trade)
- Arbitration is faster, confidential, and enforceable across borders (under the New York Convention 1958, to which India is a signatory).
- Common forums:
- Indian Council of Arbitration (ICA) – for Indian exporters/importers.
- Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC).
- ICC Arbitration Court (Paris).
- Seat of Arbitration: Decide whether proceedings happen in India or abroad.
- Enforcement: Foreign arbitral awards are enforceable in India under Part II of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
C. Litigation (Last Resort)
- Costly and time-consuming — usually avoided unless the contract lacks an arbitration clause.
- If the counterparty is abroad, enforcing Indian court judgments can be difficult unless that country has a reciprocal arrangement (under Section 44A, CPC).
4. Support Mechanisms for Indian Traders
Indian Institutions and Avenues
- Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT): Helps resolve disputes linked to export-import policy violations.
- Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (ECGC): Provides protection against payment defaults by foreign buyers.
- Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO): Offers mediation, trade counseling, and buyer-seller dispute assistance.
- Chambers of Commerce: e.g., FICCI, ASSOCHAM, and CII — facilitate arbitration or negotiation.
- Indian Council of Arbitration (ICA): Specialized in trade-related arbitration.
5. Practical Steps for Indian Traders in Case of a Dispute
Step | Action | Objective |
1. Document everything | Collect emails, contracts, invoices, shipping documents, inspection reports. | Establish facts. |
2. Notify the counterparty | Send formal notice of breach and seek amicable settlement. | Preserve right to claim. |
3. Engage legal/trade experts | Consult international trade lawyer or arbitration professional. | Strategize response. |
4. Attempt mediation/conciliation | Approach trade bodies like FIEO, ICC, or ICA. | Save time and relationship. |
5. Invoke arbitration clause | File claim as per agreed procedure (seat, institution). | Formal dispute resolution. |
6. Enforce award or judgment | Use Indian or foreign courts depending on seat of arbitration. | Recover compensation. |
6. Example Scenario
Situation: An Indian exporter supplies garments to a European buyer. Buyer delays payment citing quality defects.
Resolution Path:
- Exporter contacts buyer ? fails to settle.
- FIEO mediation ? unsuccessful.
- Arbitration initiated under ICC clause in contract (seat: Singapore).
- Award passed in exporter’s favor.
- Award enforced in buyer’s country under New York Convention.
7. Key Takeaways
- Always include clear dispute resolution and governing law clauses in contracts.
- Prefer arbitration over court litigation.
- Use institutional support (DGFT, FIEO, ECGC, ICA).
- Maintain strong documentation and insurance.
- Engage qualified international trade lawyers early.
***