Just a moment...

⚠ ✕
❮ Top
☎ Help
☰
×

By creating an account you can:

Logo TaxTMI
Keyword Search :
AI Tools : New
Ask tax questions in natural language. Powered by AI trained on the TaxTMI legal database. Use AI Tools ➞
Call Us / Help / Feedback✕

Contact Us At :

✉ E-mail: [email protected]

✆ Call / WhatsApp at: +91 99117 96707

For more information, Check Contact Us

FAQs :

To know Frequently Asked Questions, Check FAQs

Most Asked Video Tutorials :

For more tutorials, Check Video Tutorials

Submit Feedback/Suggestion :

Email :
Please provide your email address so we can follow up on your feedback.
Category :
Description :
Min 15 characters 0/2000
Make Most of Text Search ✕
  1. Checkout this video tutorial: How to search effectively on TaxTMI.
  2. Put words in double quotes for exact word search, eg: "income tax"
  3. Avoid noise words such as : 'and, of, the, a'
  4. Sort by Relevance to get the most relevant document.
  5. Press Enter to add multiple terms/multiple phrases, and then click on Search to Search.
    6. Text Search
  6. The system will try to fetch results that contains ALL your words.
  7. Once you add keywords, you'll see a new 'Search In' filter that makes your results even more precise.
    8. Text Search
╳
Add to...
You have not created any category. Kindly create one to bookmark this item!
✕
Create New Category
Hide
Title :
Description :
❮❮ Hide
❮ Default View
Expand ❯❯
Close ✕
🔎 TMI Notes - Adv. Search ❯
TEXT SEARCH:

Press 'Enter' to add multiple search terms. Rules for Better Search

Search In:
Main Text + AI Text ❯
  • Main Text
  • Main Text + AI Text
  • AI Text
Law:
---- All Laws---- ❯
  • ---- All Laws----
  • Benami Property
  • Bill
  • Central Excise
  • Companies Law
  • Customs
  • DGFT
  • FEMA
  • GST
  • GST - States
  • IBC
  • Income Tax
  • Indian Laws
  • Money Laundering
  • SEBI
  • SEZ
  • Service Tax
  • VAT / Sales Tax
Types:
---- All Types ---- ❯
  • ---- All Types ----
  • Act Rules
  • Case Laws
  • Circulars
  • Manuals
  • News
  • Notifications
Sort By: ?
In Sort By 'Default', exact matches for text search are shown at the top, followed by the remaining results in their regular order.
Relevance Default Date
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether proceedings can be reopened on the basis of a favourable decision in another case?
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether a wrong decision by jurisdictional court is binding on the parties in absence of any appeal ...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether an order becomes a final order if no appeal has been filed against it?
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether right to appeal is a inherent right? Whether it is necessary that right of appeal must be ex...
    Manuals Service Tax
    What is the meaning of 'Reason to Believe' in context to search & seizure provisions?
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether in case, composite price (inclusive of service tax) is shown in invoice and no separate duty...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether Doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable on finalisation of provisional assessments?
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether Doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable on duty paid under protest?
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether data in "CD" can be a admissible evidence for refund claim under Section 11B? Whether data i...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether limitation of refund filing is applicable on the cases where amount paid to the department a...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether deposit of service tax before rendering services will be covered under limitation of refund...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether Appellate authority has empowered to increase the penalty? Whether Appellate authority can i...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether the penalty under section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 can be reduced below the minimum limit...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether the penalty under Section 76 of the Finance Act, 1994 can be reduced below the limit prescri...
    Act Rules Service Tax
    Whether Service tax paid by back calculations i.e. service tax separately not charged will be covere...
    Act Rules Service Tax
    Whether assessee is liable to pay collected service tax as per provision of Sec.73A even if his turn...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether ignorance of law can be a factor for not to revoke extended period of limitation?
    Manuals Service Tax
    In what circumstances extended period of limitation is not enforceable? Whether SCN can be issued fo...
    Act Rules Service Tax
    Whether show cause notice related to period beyond 18 months or 5 years as the case may be, is valid...
    Manuals Service Tax
    Whether it is mandatory to mention specific head / sub head of services in SCN in which demand of se...
❮
❯
❯❯
Maximize Maximize Maximize
0 / 200
Expand Note
Add to Folder

No Folders have been created

+

Are you sure you want to delete "My most important" ?

NOTE:

Open Link
Notes
Showing Results for :
Reset Filters
Results Found:
Show All Summaries Hide All Summaries
Manuals Service Tax
Whether proceedings can be reopened on the basis of a favourable decision in another case?
Show AI Summary
Finality of proceedings: tax assessments cannot be reopened due to another taxpayer's favourable decision without recall in the same case.
Reopening tax assessment proceedings based on a favourable decision in another assessee's case is ordinarily not permitted; a final order in an assessee's own case remains effective until it is specifically recalled or set aside in that same proceeding.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether a wrong decision by jurisdictional court is binding on the parties in absence of any appeal ...
Show AI Summary
Finality of unappealed decisions: unchallenged jurisdictional rulings bind the parties until lawfully reversed.
A jurisdictional court's unappealed ruling, even if incorrect, becomes final and binding between the parties and remains so until reversed by a higher forum or other statutory remedy; thus unchallenged classificatory or determinative decisions must be obeyed in subsequent proceedings unless lawfully set aside.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether an order becomes a final order if no appeal has been filed against it?
Show AI Summary
Finality of administrative orders follows when no appeal is filed, and remand directions limit reconsideration scope.
An administrative order attains finality where an entitled party does not file an appeal against a Tribunal disposition; remand orders limit reconsideration to the specific issues directed by the Tribunal, and parties who do not contest merits before the Tribunal forfeit the ability to re argue those merits, so that authorities acting on remand cannot expand review beyond the remand directions.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether right to appeal is a inherent right? Whether it is necessary that right of appeal must be ex...
Show AI Summary
Right of appeal is not inherent; it exists only when statute creates and defines it, including scope and procedure.
The right of appeal is not inherent but is a statutory construct: appellate existence, scope and procedure must be authorized by the creating provision; omissions in citation do not automatically bar an otherwise maintainable appeal; absence of an appellate provision does not prevent an order from becoming final.
Manuals Service Tax
What is the meaning of 'Reason to Believe' in context to search & seizure provisions?
Show AI Summary
Reason to believe requires subjective belief grounded in material evidence, preventing arbitrary or capricious searches.
The concept of reason to believe requires that a subjective opinion be based on material on the record, not arbitrary or whimsical; it must be held in good faith and courts may test whether the reasons have a rational and relevant connection to the formation of belief, excluding extraneous considerations.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether in case, composite price (inclusive of service tax) is shown in invoice and no separate duty...
Show AI Summary
Inclusive pricing does not establish passing on of tax burden; composite invoices alone do not prove unjust enrichment.
Showing a composite price on an invoice does not, by itself, establish that the supplier passed the tax burden to customers or realized unjust enrichment; where prices remained unchanged after a tax was imposed, inclusive pricing alone is insufficient evidence that any element of tax was added to the price, and proof of an added tax component is required to infer passing on of the tax.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether Doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable on finalisation of provisional assessments?
Show AI Summary
Doctrine of unjust enrichment excluded where a refund arises only after finalisation of provisional assessment.
The doctrine of unjust enrichment does not apply to refund claims that arise after the finalisation of provisional assessments; refunds or recoveries consequent on the final determination of duty liability fall outside the interim statutory refund framework and are not barred by unjust enrichment objections.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether Doctrine of unjust enrichment is applicable on duty paid under protest?
Show AI Summary
Unjust enrichment doctrine not bar to refund of duty paid under protest; provisional assessments preserve refund entitlement.
The doctrine of unjust enrichment does not bar refund claims for duty paid under protest; recoveries or refunds consequent on final determination of duty liability fall outside bars that would deny restitution. Provisional assessments and unresolved price and classification lists render clearances provisional, supporting the taxpayer's entitlement to have refund claims adjudicated on the basis of final liability rather than dismissed as struck by unjust enrichment.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether data in "CD" can be a admissible evidence for refund claim under Section 11B? Whether data i...
Show AI Summary
Admissibility of electronic records: computerised data on CD can support service tax refund claims and show no transfer of tax burden.
Data on compact disc (CD) can be admissible evidence for service tax refund claims where it constitutes computerised records recognised under the Information Technology Act and the Service Tax Rules. Such electronic records may also be used to prove that the incidence of service tax was not transferred to another party (absence of unjust enrichment), provided the data meets the statutory criteria for admissible computerised evidence and forms part of the assessee's maintained electronic records.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether limitation of refund filing is applicable on the cases where amount paid to the department a...
Show AI Summary
Limitation on refund filings: time-bar inapplicable where payments were not service tax and were excess realisations.
Limitation under Section 11B(1) applies only to refund claims of a duty of excise and interest; payments not constituting service tax or lawful excise levy are outside that bar and may be refunded. Judicial authorities (M/s Natraj and Venkat Associates; ITC Ltd.) recognise that excess realisations beyond what the statute permits are realisations outside the Act and thus not subject to the statutory limitation on excise refunds.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether deposit of service tax before rendering services will be covered under limitation of refund...
Show AI Summary
Limitation on service tax refunds: late claims are barred unless tax was paid under protest.
Refunds of amounts paid as service tax are governed by the statutory limitation provisions; where payments were credited to the service tax account and the claimant acknowledged applicability of the limitation rule, a refund claim filed after the limitation period is barred unless the tax was paid under protest.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether Appellate authority has empowered to increase the penalty? Whether Appellate authority can i...
Show AI Summary
Appellate authority power to increase penalties is limited; payment of tax and interest can justify mitigation of penalty.
Appellate authority does not have power to increase or impose a fresh penalty; payment of tax and interest that neutralises pecuniary advantage is relevant for mitigation, and taxpayer status and proportionality are material in assessing whether a revised penalty is unduly harsh under the statutory penalty framework.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether the penalty under section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 can be reduced below the minimum limit...
Show AI Summary
Penalty minimums prohibited from reduction: statutory scheme prevents lowering prescribed service tax penalty through discretionary provisions.
Penalty under section 78 of the Finance Act, 1994 cannot be reduced below the statutory minimum by invoking section 80; a conjoint reading of the provisions shows no discretion to levy or reduce a penalty below the prescribed floor, and appellate bodies and tribunals cannot read such power into the statutory scheme.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether the penalty under Section 76 of the Finance Act, 1994 can be reduced below the limit prescri...
Show AI Summary
Penalty under Section 76 cannot be reduced below the statutory minimum; authority's discretion is confined to the prescribed range.
Section 76 penalty under the Finance Act, 1994 confines the authority to a legislatively prescribed minimum-to-maximum range; authorities lack power to reduce the penalty below the statutory minimum per day of default, and courts have rejected construing any additional discretion into the provision as that would amount to rewriting the statute.
Act Rules Service Tax
Whether Service tax paid by back calculations i.e. service tax separately not charged will be covere...
Show AI Summary
Service tax deposit obligations do not arise where tax was not invoiced or collected, limiting unjust enrichment claims.
Where no invoice was raised and no amount was specifically collected as service tax from recipients, the statutory duty to deposit such tax does not arise because there is no collected tax to be held on behalf of the Government, and absence of pass through means the legal condition for invoking unjust enrichment is not satisfied.
Act Rules Service Tax
Whether assessee is liable to pay collected service tax as per provision of Sec.73A even if his turn...
Show AI Summary
Deposit of collected service tax must be remitted even if small provider exempt; penalties apply for non-deposit.
Section 73A requires that service tax collected from customers be deposited with the Central Government even if the collector avails the small service provider exemption; tribunals have held that collection triggers an obligatory deposit and failure to deposit and to file returns attracts penal action and enforcement for non-compliance.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether ignorance of law can be a factor for not to revoke extended period of limitation?
Show AI Summary
Ignorance of law or illiteracy can undermine findings of willful suppression, affecting the validity of tax demand and penalties.
Administrative demands and penalties based on alleged willful suppression of taxable services require supporting record evidence and must correspond to allegations in the show cause notice; where the record does not substantiate suppression and the allegation was not made in the notice, the resultant service tax demand and penalties are not sustainable.
Manuals Service Tax
In what circumstances extended period of limitation is not enforceable? Whether SCN can be issued fo...
Show AI Summary
Extended limitation period: not available where assessee had bona fide belief or doubt about service tax liability.
Extended limitation cannot be invoked where the assessee had a bona fide belief that no service tax was payable, where bona fide doubt existed about chargeability, where the assessee voluntarily approached the department earlier, where the issue is one of legal interpretation creating genuine confusion, or where earlier favorable decisions were subsequently overruled without evidence of suppression.
Act Rules Service Tax
Whether show cause notice related to period beyond 18 months or 5 years as the case may be, is valid...
Show AI Summary
Limitation for recovery of service tax prevents collection for time barred periods but notice remains partly effective.
A show cause notice that includes periods beyond the statutory limitation does not become wholly invalid; the Department cannot recover tax for time barred periods, and the assessee may raise the limitation defence during proceedings. The same rule applies to notices extending beyond a shorter statutory limitation-the excess period yields no departmental entitlement to recovery but does not vitiate valid allegations within the limitation.
Manuals Service Tax
Whether it is mandatory to mention specific head / sub head of services in SCN in which demand of se...
Show AI Summary
Specific service allegation: tax liability cannot be confirmed unless the show-cause notice specifies the service head.
A show-cause notice must specifically identify the service head or sub-head relied upon; absent a precise allegation as to the applicable classification, tax liability cannot be confirmed, and alternative classifications suggested by the Commissioner without being pleaded in the notice render any demand unsustainable.

TMI Notes

Back

All TMI Notes

Showing Results for :
Reset Filters
No Records Found

TMI Notes

Home › TMI Notes › Income Tax › Act-Rules › Category › This
Back

All TMI Notes

whatsapp Join Channel
Showing Results for : Reset Filters
Income Tax

Comparison of Section 11 "Incomes not included in total income" between the Income-Tax Act, 2025 (as passed) and the Income-Tax Bill, 2025 (as originally introduced)

19 August, 2025

Contents
Acts
Rules & Regulations
Summary
Note

Note

-

Bookmark

Print

Print

Print Options

Section 11 Incomes not included in total income.

Income-tax Act, 2025 [As Passed]

At a Glance

The document considered is Clause 11 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025 (Old Version), titled "Incomes not included in total income." It sets out that incomes enumerated in certain Schedules (II-VI) are excluded from total income subject to conditions, and that persons in Schedule VII may be not chargeable to tax subject to conditions. It matters to taxpayers, tax practitioners, and the tax department as it defines categories and conditions for tax-exempt incomes. Effective date or decision date: Not stated in the document.

Background & Scope

Statutory hook: Clause 11 of Chapter III of the Income Tax Bill, 2025 (Old Version), titled "Incomes not included in total income." The clause enumerates the schedules (II, III, IV, V and VI) whose items are not to be included in computing total income, subject to conditions specified in those Schedules. It also addresses persons in Schedule VII who may not be chargeable to tax for a tax year, subject to conditions in Schedule VII. The clause empowers the Central Government to make rules or notifications for the purposes of this section as specified in Schedules II-VII.

Statutory Provision Mode

Text & Scope

Clause 11 provides a framework for certain incomes and persons to be excluded from the computation of total income under the Act, subject to qualifying conditions specified in schedules II, III, IV, V and VI (for incomes) and Schedule VII (for persons). The operative structure is:

  • Sub-section (1): Prescribes that any income enumerated in Schedules II, III, IV, V, and VI shall not be included in computing the total income of any person for a tax year, subject to fulfilment of the conditions specified in those Schedules.
  • Sub-section (2): States that where the conditions in those Schedules are not satisfied in any tax year in respect of any income enumerated therein, such income shall be charged to tax under the Act for that tax year.
  • Sub-section (3): Provides that persons enumerated in Schedule VII shall, subject to fulfilment of the conditions specified therein, not be chargeable to tax under the Act for a tax year.
  • Sub-section (4): Provides that where the conditions in Schedule VII are not satisfied, the income of such person shall be charged to tax under the provisions of the Act.
  • Sub-section (5): Empowers the Central Government to make rules or issue notifications for the purposes of the section as specified in Schedules II-VII.

Interpretation

Legislative intent and interpretive principles indicated by the text: The clause establishes a conditional exclusion regime - certain items or persons are excluded from "total income" only upon fulfillment of conditions specified in the referenced Schedules. The presence of sub-sections (2) and (4) indicates a default rule: failure to meet conditions results in taxability. The provision's structure contemplates administrable conditions and the need for rule-making by the Central Government to operationalise the Schedules. Specific legislative intent beyond this structure: Not stated in the document.

Exceptions/Provisos

The clause itself incorporates the exceptions: the exclusion of incomes/persons is conditional. Specific provisos, thresholds, or exceptions applicable to particular incomes or persons are not contained in Clause 11 but are to be found in Schedules II-VII. Therefore: Not stated in the document (for schedule-specific carve-outs).

Illustrations

  • Example 1: If an income type A is enumerated in Schedule II and the taxpayer satisfies the conditions in Schedule II for tax year Y, income A is not included in total income for year Y. (Specifics of income A and conditions: Not stated in the document.)

  • Example 2: If a person P is enumerated in Schedule VII but fails to satisfy the conditions of Schedule VII in tax year Z, the income of P for year Z shall be charged to tax under the Act. (Specifics of P and the conditions: Not stated in the document.)

Interplay

Interaction with Rules/Notifications/Circulars: Clause 11 expressly empowers the Central Government to make rules or issue notifications for the purposes specified in Schedules II-VII. No references to particular existing Rules or Circulars are provided in the clause. Any detailed interplay with other provisions of the Bill/Act, or with administrative guidance, is: Not stated in the document.

Differences Between Section 11 (As Passed) and Clause 11 (Old Version)

  • Punctuation and enumeration: The passed version (Section 11) lists "Schedules II, III, IV V and VI" (missing comma between IV and V), whereas the Old Version lists "Schedules II, III, IV, V, and VI."
    • Practical impact: purely typographical; no substantive legal effect if schedules are otherwise unambiguous.
  • Reference to charging to tax - scope wording in sub-section (2): Old Version states that, where conditions are not satisfied, such income "shall be charged to tax under this Act for that tax year." The passed version states such income "shall be charged to tax under this Act on the total income for that tax year."
    • Practical impact: the passed version expressly clarifies that the income will be included in "total income" for that tax year. This is a clarification of basis of charging (inclusion in total income) rather than a substantive change in taxability; it may reduce ambiguity about the tax base into which the income is to be placed.
  • Sub-section (3) wording - persons in Schedule VII: Old Version: "not be chargeable to tax under this Act for a tax year." Passed version: "not be chargeable to tax under this Act on the total income for a tax year."
    • Practical impact: same as above - the passed text clarifies the basis (total income) of the non-chargeability rather than altering who escapes tax; again primarily clarificatory.
  • Sub-section (4) temporal clarity: Old Version states that if conditions in Schedule VII are not satisfied, "the income of such person shall be charged to tax under the provisions of this Act." The passed version adds "for that tax year."
    • Practical impact: the passed text makes explicit the temporal application (the specific tax year), reducing potential interpretive uncertainty about retroactivity or broader application; substantive tax effect is unlikely changed.
  • Overall drafting changes: The passed version uses explicit references to "total income" in sub-sections (2) and (3) and reiterates temporal limitation in sub-section (4).
    • Practical impact: these are drafting clarifications that make legislative intent about the tax base and tax year explicit, aiding interpretation and administration; they do not introduce new substantive tax exemptions or conditions beyond those already stated in the schedules.
  • Ancillary commentary: The Old Version includes an editorial explanatory sentence (a short clause summary) after the provision text; the passed version does not contain that sentence in the provided excerpt.
    • Practical impact: none on legal effect; the summary is explanatory material that may assist readers but not part of statutory text.

Practical Implications

  • Compliance and risk areas: Clause 11 places the onus on taxpayers and persons benefited by schedule-based exclusions to ensure that conditions in the relevant Schedules are met each tax year. Failure to satisfy conditions converts an exclusion into taxable income for that tax year-thus risk of unintended tax liability exists where compliance with schedule-conditions is insufficient or not documented. The specifics of compliance duties are set out in the Schedules and rules (Not stated in the document).
  • Record-keeping/evidence: Given the conditional nature of exclusions, stakeholders should expect to maintain evidence demonstrating fulfillment of schedule conditions (nature of evidence, forms, timelines: Not stated in the document). The Central Government's rule-making power suggests additional procedural requirements may follow in subordinate legislation or notifications.

Key Takeaways

  • Clause 11 establishes a conditional exemption framework: listed incomes (Schedules II-VI) and listed persons (Schedule VII) are excluded from total income subject to schedule-specific conditions.
  • Failure to satisfy schedules' conditions results in chargeability to tax for the relevant tax year.
  • The provision empowers the Central Government to issue rules or notifications to operationalise the schedules, indicating procedural detail will be provided by subordinate legislation.
  • The Old Version is largely administrative and structural; the substantive content of exemptions and conditions resides in the referenced Schedules, which are not reproduced in this clause.
  • Clause 11 shifts legal focus to compliance with schedule conditions and documentation to sustain exclusions.

Full Text:

Section 11 Incomes not included in total income.

Topics

Acts Income Tax
Next ➔