TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
Legal Architecture of PAN, Aadhaar, and High-Value Transaction : Clause 262 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025 Vs. Section 139A of the Income Tax Act, 1961
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....empts to harmonize the traditional PAN system with the Aadhaar ecosystem, reflecting a policy shift towards greater traceability, transparency, and ease of doing business. This commentary undertakes a detailed provision-wise analysis of Clause 262, juxtaposing it with the existing statutory and regulatory framework, and evaluates the practical, legal, and policy implications of the proposed changes. 2. Objective and Purpose The core objectives underlying Clause 262 are as follows: * To mandate the allotment and quoting of PAN for specified classes of persons and transactions, thereby creating a unique identifier for tax and financial purposes. * To integrate the PAN system with Aadhaar, facilitating seamless authentication and reducing duplication or fraudulent acquisition of multiple PANs. * To specify the obligations of quoting and authenticating PAN/Aadhaar in prescribed transactions, thereby enhancing traceability of financial flows. * To empower the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) and the Central Government to prescribe rules, exempt certain classes, and notify additional requirements as needed. * To provide for the penal consequences for non-compliance, as go....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....orrespondence with income-tax authorities, and in all challans for payments under the Act. Comparison: This is identical to Section 139A(5)(a) and (b), and is further operationalized by Rule 114B, which lists specific transactions (e.g., purchase of motor vehicles, opening bank accounts, large cash deposits, property transactions, etc.) where quoting PAN is mandatory. 3.4. Intimation of Changes (Sub-section 4) Any change in address, name, or nature of business must be intimated to the Assessing Officer. Comparison: This is a direct carry-forward from Section 139A(5)(d), ensuring the tax department's records are current and accurate. 3.5. Aadhaar-PAN Linkage (Sub-sections 5, 6, and 7) * Sub-section 5: Mandatory quoting of Aadhaar in PAN application and return of income by eligible persons. * Sub-section 6: Mandatory intimation of Aadhaar by PAN holders; failure results in inoperative PAN. * Sub-section 7: Permits quoting of Aadhaar in lieu of PAN in prescribed situations; PAN is allotted to such persons as prescribed. Comparison: These provisions are analogous to Section 139AA (not directly Section 139A) and Section 139A(5E) of the 1961 Act, which introduced Aadhaar-....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... mirror those in the Explanation to Section 139A and Section 139AA, ensuring consistency of terminology. 4. Practical Implications 4.1. For Individuals and Businesses * Obligatory PAN application for specified persons and transactions increases compliance requirements, especially for those engaging in high-value transactions. * Integration with Aadhaar reduces documentation burden but raises privacy and data security considerations. * Potential inoperability of PAN for non-linkage with Aadhaar could disrupt financial and tax-related activities. * Prohibition on multiple PANs prevents misuse but necessitates vigilance in application processes. 4.2. For Financial Institutions and Intermediaries * Obligation to collect, verify, and authenticate PAN/Aadhaar in prescribed transactions increases operational responsibilities. * Failure to comply may attract penalties u/s 272B. * Need for robust IT systems to handle authentication and reporting requirements as per Rules 114BB, 114B, etc. 4.3. For Non-Residents and Special Entities * Rule 114AAB provides exemptions for specified non-residents investing in alternative investment funds or transacting in IFSCs, subject to d....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....igh-value property transactions, large cash deposits, opening bank accounts, etc.). Clause 262(9) and (10)(c) are the enabling provisions. * Rule 114BA: Specifies additional transactions (e.g., large cash deposits/withdrawals, opening current/cash credit accounts) that trigger PAN application requirements. Clause 262(1) and (10)(b) provide the legislative basis. * Rule 114BB: Prescribes quoting and authentication requirements for high-value cash transactions, and designates the responsible persons for verification. Clause 262(9) and (10)(e) are the source of authority. These rules operationalize the broad mandates of Clause 262/Section 139A, ensuring that the legislative intent is realized through detailed administrative requirements. 6. Ambiguities and Potential Issues * Overlap and Complexity: The interplay between PAN and Aadhaar, and the multiplicity of rules and notifications, can create confusion for taxpayers and intermediaries, especially regarding exemptions and procedural nuances. * Privacy Concerns: The increased use of Aadhaar raises legitimate privacy and data security issues, especially given the sensitivity of biometric and demographic data. * Procedural ....