TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2024 (6) TMI 1413
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e appellant, he further submits that the TDS was deducted from the payment made to the directors and form 16 was issued. Therefore, the said remuneration which was paid under the head of salary would not attract Service Tax he placed Reliance on various following Judgments and board circulars:- • Allied Blenders and Distillers Pvt Ltd Vs. C.C.E & S.T. Aurangabad - 2019 (24) G.S.T.L. 207 (Tri.-Mumbai) • Vectus Industries Ltd Vs. Commissioner of Service Tax - Final Order No. 71942/2019 dated 26.11.2019 of the CESTAT, Allahabad • Maithan Alloys Ltd Vs. Commissioner of C.Ex. & S.T. Bolpur - 2020 (33) G.S.T.L. 228 (Tri.-Kolkata) • Bengal Beverages Pvt Ltd Vs. CGST & Excise, Howrah - Final Order No. 7556l / 2020 dated 09.10.2020 of the CESTAT, Kolkata 2.1. He further submits that in the above referred circular also board has clarified that remuneration such as paid in the present case not liable for Service Tax. Therefore, the issue no longer res integra accordingly the impugned orders are not sustainable. 3. Shri Rajesh R Kurup, learned Superintendent (AR) appearing on behalf of the revenue reiterates the finding of the impugned ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... merely, - (i) a transfer of title in goods or immovable property, by way of sale, gift or in any other manner; or (ii) such transfer, delivery or supply of any goods which is deemed to be a sale within the meaning of clause (29A) of Article 366 of the Constitution, or (iii) a transaction in money or actionable claim; (b) a provision of service by an employee to the employer in the course of or in relation to his employment; (c) fees taken in any Court or tribunal established under any law for the time being in force. 7. The appellants are taking shelter of clause (b) of the definition of 'service'. Advancing the arguments on behalf of the appellant, Ld. Advocate submits that since the relation between the appellant and the four Directors are in the nature of employer and employee hence, no Service Tax is payable by the appellant on the remuneration paid to these directors which is nothing but 'salary' being paid to an employee. 8. The Ld. Advocate for the appellant referring to various provisions of the Companies Act vehemently argued that these four directors were appointed as full-time/whole time directors of the com....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....he Board of Directors. 9. All the four Directors were appointed by the resolutions passed by the Board of Directors (BOD). The resolution for Mr. Chabria is as below : Similar resolutions have been passed by the BOD for other Director also. 10. We find that the appellant have placed on record the Form-16 issued by the appellant indicating deduction of income tax at source on the salary paid to each of the Directors. Besides, the appellant had also produced the contribution made to the Employees Provident Fund for each of the Directors, as required in case of other employees under the relevant laws. The statement furnished for all the employees by the Appellant reflects the name of the directors also. Copy EPF Return showing the name Mr. K.R. Chhabria in the list of employees is as below : 11. Similarly, the Form-32 as required to be filed under the Companies Act, with the Registrar of companies, the four directors are shown as executive directors indicating that they are employees of the company. 12. Both sides heavily relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ram Pershad v. CIT, New Delhi - (1972) 2 SCC 696 deli....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....spect of the manner he should do the work nor in respect of the day to day work, he is required to do, he may nonetheless be a servant if his employment creates a relationship of master and servant. Similar is the case of a chauffeur who is employed to drive the car for his employer. If he is to take the employer or any other person at his request from place 'A' to place 'B' the employer does not supervise the manner in which he drives between those places. Such examples can be multiplied. A person who is engaged to manage a business may be a servant or an agent according to the nature of his service and the authority of his employment. Generally it may be possible to say that the greater the amount of direct control over the person employed, the stronger the conclusion in favour of his being a servant. Similarly the greater the degree of independence the greater the possibility of the services rendered being in the nature of principal and agent. It is not possible to lay down any precise rule of law to distinguish one kind of employment from the other. The nature of the particular business and the nature of the duties of the employee will require to be considered in each case in o....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....Director he functions also as a member of the Board of Directors whose collective decisions he has to carry out in terms of the articles of association and he can do nothing which he is not permitted to do. Under s. 17(2) of the Indian Companies Act 1913 Regulation No. 71 of Table A which enjoins that the business of the company shall be managed by the directors is deemed to be continued in the articles of association of the company in identical term or to the same effect. Since the Board of Directors are to manage the business of the Company they have every right to control and supervise the assessee's work whenever they deem it necessary. Every power which is given to the Managing Director therefore emanates from the articles of association which prescribes the limits of the exercise of that power. The powers of the assessee have to be exercised within the terms and limitations prescribed thereunder and subject to the control and supervision of the Directors which in our view is indicative of his being employed as a servant of the company." (emphasis supplied) 13. The Learned Advocate submits that the Board of Directors exercises control which includes removal o....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....te only in Board Meetings and consequently paid remuneration. 16. Also, from the documents produced by the appellant it is crystal clear that the Directors who are concerned with the management of the company, were declared to all statutory authorities as employees of the company and complied with the provisions of the respective Acts, Rules and Regulations indicating the Director as an employee of the company. No contrary evidence has been brought on record by the Revenue to show that the Directors, who were employee of the appellant received amount which cannot be said as ' salary' but fees paid for being Director of the company. The Income Tax authorities also assessed the remuneration paid to the said directors as salary, a fact cannot be ignored. The judgments cited by the revenue cannot be applied to the present case as the facts are different and the finding of Income tax authorities accordingly also different in the said case. 17. In these circumstances, we do not find merit in the impugned order. Consequently, the impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed." On the identical issue this Tribunal following above decision in the case of Supreme....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... (ii) applicability of service tax on Independent Directors who are part of the Board of Directors under 'Management Consultant service. 2. Both the matters have been examined by the Board and the clarifications are as under. - (i) Some Companies make payments to Managing Directors/Directors (Whole-time or Independent). terming the same as 'Commissions'. The said amount paid by a company to their Managing Director/Directors (Whole-time or Independent) even if termed as commission, is not the 'commission' that is within the scope of business auxiliary service and hence service tax would not be leviable on such amount. (ii) The Managing Director/Directors (Whole-time or Independent) being part of Board of Directors perform management function and they do not perform consultancy or advisory function. The definition of management consultant service makes it clear that what is envisaged from a consultant is advisory service and not the actual performance of the management function. The payments made by Companies, to Directors cannot be termed as payments for providing management consultancy service. Therefore, it is clarified that ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....g activity for the reason that such insurance policies addresses the financial risks of the manufacturer. Further, in the case of Granules India Ltd. (supra), the Tribunal has held that the credit availed on directors' liability insurance is eligible. I find that the disallowance of credit on this input service is unjustified and requires to be set aside, which I hereby do. 6. The second issue for consideration is regarding the eligibility of credit on service tax paid on Director Sitting Fees. The said issue is covered by the decision in the case of SKN Organics P. Ltd. (supra). Further, it is also to be stated that it is the duty of the director to attend the meetings and therefore the service tax paid on such fees is eligible for credit. 7. From the discussions made above, I am of the view that the disallowance of credit on the impugned services is incorrect and requires to be set aside, which I hereby do. The impugned order is set aside and the appeal is allowed with consequential relief, if any." In view of the above discussions and findings, we are of the view that the appellant is legally entitled the Cenvat credit in respect of the Service Tax paid on ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....00000 166667 2000000 Life Insurance Premium 250000 3000000 250000 1000000 Premium for Personal Accident 16600 199200 Total (8) 768267 9219200 16600 768267 199200 BETIREMENT BENETITS Provident Fund 240000 2850000 250704 9219200 3008448 Total (C) 240000 2830000 250704 TOTAL PACKAGE (A+B+C 3639267 43671200 3894071 3608448 46728248 Gretulky OTHER BENEFITS Ges & Electricity Residential Telephone & Mobile Club Fees As per Granity Act As per Gratuity Act Actuals Actuals Achals Actuals Leave Actuals uplo a marimum of three clubs. Foar (4) weeks leave in every financial year Mr. K. R. Chhabris being interested Director did not participate in the proceedings of this item and abstained from voting thereon. Certified True Copy For Allied Blenders And Distillers Private Limited Viyana R. L. Jala Company Secretary Actuals Ð¿Ñ€Ð¾Ñ OF three 2 clubs. Four (4) weeks leave in every financial year Allied Blenders And Distillers Pvt. Ltd Registered Office 394/C Ground Floor Lamington Chambers....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....XRM 1889 o 23 and SAHAY MAHESH VASANT 43900 6500 7376 9270 541 Sta o GOOD047 BANKAR DAS 24400 6000 2008 2020 641 541 2307 2397 0 0 Line 00000 TYAGI 000004 VA DEVENDRA VEHWAS GAWAND 0000 6500 GOOD GOOD 514 543 3950 3659 - Ñто DSCIO BASC 6400 543 2000 2003 D 26 6000052 GUPTA GAUTAM KUMAR 20200 24245 2424 543 541 1003 27 EXTESH WACHANI 23400 G530 2000 2000 543 541 2267 • 20 0000063 CINES (CHARA PGGOO 6500 65.44 6144 543 543 2331 1863 2267 2531 ° 13 ì´ 0 20 00000 32 33 34 29 0000064 DVIGASI BABU DOD0067 SAKHARAM PALAW RAJANIGUNNAR 000006 MAHESHKULKARNI ODCOUYA HAR 0000070K BALDEVAN 32500 800 29gan 741 341 Q Q SHRDHAR 0 ì´ ol ì´ 0 0 0 Q 200 6500 9402 $403 641 542 2861 201 D B 35700 6500 4204 4254 541 543 3748 3743 0 17000 2148 2148 543 1007 1007 ° 100 G....