TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2024 (6) TMI 646
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....-09 as Short Term Capital Gain (STCG) (Rs. 52,80,000/-) as against the same being correctly assessable in AY 2009-10 as Long Term Capital Gain (LTCG) (Rs. 36,29,880/-) as returned by the assessee . In AY 2009-10, the LTCG has been assessed on protective basis and this issue is in appeal before the Hon'ble ITAT for AY 2009-10. 2. That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in considering the date of agreement to sell 08.03.2008 as the date of transfer on mere receipt of 10% advance, whereas the transfer took place in the next year only pursuant to completion of full and final payment, on handing over of original documents and on transfer of booking by builder in the name of the buyer i.e. in AY 2009-10. There is no transfer of the capital asset involved in AY 2008-09. 3. The core issue to be decided in this appeal is with regard to the year of transfer of capital asset pursuant to the agreement to sale and consequentially decide whether it is short-term or long-term capital gain. 4. We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. The return for assessment year 2008-09 was filed by the assessee declaring total income of Rs.1,14,04,810/-. The income disclos....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....he sake of convenience, the said clause 16 of allotment letter dated 9.4.2005 is reproduced below:- "16. The buyer is not entitled to transfer/encumber his rights under this allotment till the sale of the house in his favour is completed except with prior written consent of the builder on payment of outstandings and such administrative charges as may be specified by the builder in this behalf. The subsequent transferees shall be bound by the terms of this allotment in all respects" 6. As seen from the terms of the said agreement to sell, it was only an agreement to sell wherein transfer of booking rights were to be completed subsequently on fulfillment of certain conditions, more particularly - (i) the receipt of entire consideration, and (ii) receipt of NOC from builder. As on the date of Agreement to Sell, the assessee (seller herein) had only received 10% advance deposit as earnest money subject to conditions and compliances to be done. Time limit for final payment and transfer was agreed upto 30.04.2008 which fell in the next year i.e. AY 2009-10. Assessee had no power to transfer without prior written consent of builder. So, transfer was subject to consent of builder which ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....on, but section 2(47)(ii) shall be applicable which require condition of relinquishment of asset. As per the Ld. AO there was relinquishment of rights and, therefore transfer took place in AY 2008- 09. 10. On appeal by assessee against order u/s 147/143(3) in AY 2008- 09, Ld. CIT(A) confirmed the assessment of the capital gain in AY 2008- 09 as STCG applying section 2(47)(vi) on the following grounds:- a. When there is intention to convey rights in the agreement to sell, it is safe to say that the rights to obtain title/ booking rights emanated from the agreement. When such rights can be located in the buyer's agreement the date of acquisition of capital asset must be considered the date of signing of the said agreement; B. By virtue of this agreement to sell, there is transfer of actionable rights; C. Although transfer of immovable property may be conditional, nevertheless there is parting of an interest in the property i.e. Booking Rights as admitted by the assessee. The Ld. AR before us submitted that no such admission was made by the assessee; D. The agreement has the effect of parting of that right at the time of agreement which has been actuated by subsequent con....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... by Ansal Buildwell Limited. As borne out from clause-2 and 3 of the agreement to sell read with clause-16 of the allotment letter - a. The Agreement to sell specifically mentions that balance payment and transfer is to be done up to 30.4.2008 i.e. in FY 2008-09 relevant to AY 2009-10; b. On refusal of the transfer by the builder or delay beyond 30.04.2008, the seller (assessee herein) had the right to cancel the agreement to sell and to refund the advance of Rs. 15,75,000/- to the buyer; and c. even if permission is granted by the Builder, the seller has the right to refuse transfer of the booking right on payment of double the advance received. This shows that the agreement was cancellable. 13. Thus, in totality of facts and circumstances of the assessee's case as stated above, there was no transfer. The assessee was vested with entire rights in the property until consideration was received and NOC was issued by the Builder. Thus there was no extinguishment/ relinquishment of rights of the assessee. If this Agreement to sell is transfer, then capital gains shall be leviable on all the agreement to sell even on receiving small advance/earnest money which is clearly not the ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e builder M/s Ansal Buildwell Limited. Hence, it is very clear that the transfer of booking rights is subject to consent of the builder; f. ⁠The consent was given by the builder on 02.05.2008, wherein, the builder had transferred the booking rights in the name of Shri Ardaman Singh on 02.05.2008. The evidence to this effect is enclosed at page 25 of the Paper Book. 17. Hence, apparently, the transfer of capital asset (i.e. booking rights in the property) happened only on 02.05.2008, which fall in AY 2009-10 and the assessee would be justified to disclose long-term capital gain for AY 2009-10 as transfer becomes complete in AY 2009- 10. 18. We find that the ld CIT(A) had applied the provisions of section 2(47)(vi), which reads as under:- "Section 2(47) "transfer", in relation to a capital asset, includes,- (vi) any transaction (whether by way of becoming a member of, or acquiring shares in, a co-operative society, company or other association of persons or by way of any agreement or any arrangement or in any other manner whatsoever) which has the effect of transferring, or enabling the enjoyment of, any immovable property." 19. It is pertinent to note that the capital....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ened only on 02.05.2008 and thereby the transfer of booking rights would be completed only in AY 2009- 10. 22. Further the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in the case of Ushaben Jayantilal Sodhan reported in 407 ITR 276 (Guj) had an occasion to deal with the similar issue under consideration. The relevant observations made thereon are reproduced herein below:- 16. We must, however, view these transactions in the context of the provisions contained in the Act instead of confining its effect to the Transfer of Property Act and the Registration Act. As noted, Section 2(14) of the Act defines "capital asset" inter alia as a property of any kind held by an assessee. Section 2(47) of the Act defines "transfer" in relation to a capital asset to include sale, exchange or relinquishment of the asset or extinguishment of any rights therein. The term "transfer" defined u/s.2(47) of the Act, thus, has a much wider connotation, as compared to the common parlance understanding or even under the Transfer of Property Act, under which the term "transfer of property", as noted earlier, has a narrower sweep. It is, perhaps, possible to argue that the agreement to sale gives rise to a capital asset. Upo....