TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2010 (2) TMI 8
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....der of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) directing the Assessing Officer to allow the claim of depreciation as per the Income Tax Rules, 1962, for the purposes of computing the book profit under Section 115J of the Income Tax Act, 1961? 2. In this civil appeal, we are concerned with Assessment Year 1990-1991. 3. The appellant-assessee is a private limited cfxompany engaged in the manufacture and sale of Orthopaedic appliances. In the Return of Income filed, the assessee returned an income of Rs.1,50,730/-. In the Profit and Loss Account, depreciation was provided at the rates specified in Rule 5 of the Income Tax Rules,1962 ['Rules', for short]. While completing the assessment of income, the Assessing Officer re-computed the bo....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ide for depreciation as per Schedule XIV to 1956 Act, which was not applicable to the private limited companies [See Section 355 of 1956 Act]. Consequently, the appeal filed by the Department before the Tribunal stood dismissed. 4. Aggrieved by the said decision of the Tribunal, the Department preferred I.T.A. No.66 of 1999 before the High Court of Kerala which held that Section 115J of the Act was introduced in Assessment Year 1988-1989 to take care of the phenomenon of prosperous 'zero tax' Companies which had continued despite the enactment of Section 80VVA of the Act. These Companies were paying no income tax though they had profits and though they were declaring dividends.Consequently, Section 115J of the Act was inserted to l....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....l year- [a] xxxx xxxx xxxx [b] the sums specified in sub-section (4) shall be deducted, and those specified in sub-section (5) shall not be deducted. xxxx xxxx xxxx [4] In making the computation aforesaid, the following sums shall be deducted:- [a] to [j] xxxx xxxx [k] depreciation to the extent specified in section 350. Ascertainment of depreciation. 350. The amount of depreciation to be deducted in pursuance of clause (k) of sub-section (4) of section 349 shall be the amount calculated with reference to the written down value of the assets as shown by the books of the company at the end of the financial year expiring at the commencement of this Act or immediately thereafter and at the end of each subsequent financi....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....reciation as per Schedule XIV to the 1956 Act and not as per the rates specified in Rule 5 of the Income Tax Rules, 1962, as claimed by the assessee. This view of the High Court, in the present case, was similar to the view taken by it in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Malayala Manorama Company Limited, reported in [2002] 253 I.T.R. 378 (Kerala), which High Court's judgement stood reversed by the judgement of this Court in the case of Malayala Manorama Company Limited vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in [2008] 300 I.T.R.251. 7. In our view, with respect, the judgement of this Court in Malayala Manorama Company Limited vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, reported in [2008] 300 I.T.R.251. needs re-consideration for th....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....III of Schedule VI to 1956 Act have been incorporated legislatively into Section 115J of the Act. Therefore, the question of applicability of Parts II and III of Schedule VI to 1956 Act does not arise. If a Company is a MAT Company, then be it a private limited company or a public limited company, for the purposes of Section 115J of the Act, the assessee-Company has to prepare its profit and loss account in accordance with Parts II and III of Schedule VI to 1956 Act alone. If, with respect, the judgement of this Court in Malayala Manorama Company Limited [supra] is to be accepted, then the very purpose of enacting Section 115J of the Act would stand defeated, particularly when the said section does not make any distinction between public an....