AI OCR 
TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2018 (5) TMI 1895
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....d. 3. The Honorable CIT(A) failed to appreciate the fact that the appellant has applied Transitional Net Margin Method (TNMM) as Most Appropriate Method (MAM) which takes care of all such cost like involvement of working capital and interest cost for the recovery of sales proceeds from debtors. Once the AO/TPO have accepted the Transitional Net margin Method (TNMM) as Most Appropriate Method (MAM), no separate adjustment for notional interest on delayed payment is required to be adjusted. Reliance is placed on decision of jurisdictional Ahmedabad ITAT in case of Microink Ltd. v ACIT ITA No.2873/AHD/2010." 2. We will take up all these grounds of appeal together. 3. To adjudicate on this appeal, only a few material facts need to be taken note of. During the course of assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer noted that there is a delay in realization of sale invoices to the associated enterprises (AEs) inasmuch as many invoices have been realized beyond the normal credit period of 120 days from the date of the bill of lading. He was thus of the view that not charging interest on such delays in realization of dues on AEs call for an arm's length price adjustment in respe....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....A is semi-finished material which is required to be further processed and converted into saleable product. In effect thus, export to Micro USA cannot be compared with export of finished products as was done to the independent enterprises. The assessee had also pointed out that "average credit period of third parties is 120 days whereas credit period granted to Micro USA is 135 days" though "actual highest average debtor days to third parties is 161 days whereas for Micro USA it is 186 days". It was also explained that considering the time taken in shipping the semi finished goods to Micro US, its processing in US, maintenance of inventory at US and credit realization time in US, the total cycle was about 210 days, but even if bare minimum period to complete a sale cycle is taken into account, it cannot be less than 170 days. It was thus pointed out that the average credit period to Micro USA, which was 135 days, was reasonable. On the basis of these arguments, it was submitted that no ALP adjustment is warranted in respect of, what was termed as, 'excess credit period' allowed to the Micro Ink USA. None of these submissions were accepted by the TPO. He was of the view that,....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....in arm's length price on account of excess credit period is thus devoid of any legally sustainable merits or factual basis. When all these factors were pointed out to the learned Departmental Representative, he did not have much to say except to place his bland but dutiful reliance on the orders of the authorities below. However, for the reasons set out above and in the absence of any comparative price and credit period figures on comparable product to support the case of the revenue, we uphold the grievance of the assessee and direct the Assessing Officer to delete this ALP adjustment. The assessee gets the relief accordingly." 6. Learned counsel for the assessee submits that the issue being squarely covered, in favour of the assessee and on admittedly similar set of facts, there is no occasion to reconsider the matter. We are urged to follow the said decision and delete the impugned adjustment. On the other hand, while learned Departmental Representative does not dispute that this issue is squarely covered by the aforesaid decision, he submits that the aforesaid decision is "severely flawed" as no matter what is the goods sold, "a credit period is a credit period". It is a....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....pt the transfer price and still segregate AMP expenses as an international transaction," 8. By way of an example, this aspect of the matter was then explained by Hon'ble Delhi High Court as follows: "An example given below would make it clear: Particulars Case 1 Case 2 Sales 1000 1,000 Purchase Price 600 500 Gross Margin 400 (40%) 500 Marketing Sale promotion 50 150 Overhead expense 300 300 Net profit 50 (5%) 50 (5%) The above illustrations draw a distinction between two distributors having different marketing functions. In case 2, a distributor having significant marketing functions incurs substantial expenditure on AMP, three times more than in case 1, but the purchase price being lower, the Indian AE gets adequately compensated and, therefore, no transfer pricing adjustment is required. In case we treat the AMP expenses in case 2 as Rs. 501-, i.e. identical as case 1 and AMP of Rs. 100 as a separate transaction, the position in case 2 would be: Particulars Case 2 Sales 1,000 Purchase Price 500 Gross Margin 500 (50%) Overhead expenses 300 Marketing expenses 50 Net profit 150 (15%) It is....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ds, as sold to Micro USA, is not sold to any other independent enterprises. The assessee did have trading transactions in respect of the finished goods with trading subsidiaries in China and Hong Kong but it is not even the case of the TPO that excessive credit period was allowed to these AEs vis-àvis the credit period allowed to independent enterprises, nor any ALP adjustment has been recommended in connection with the same. This fact, if anything, shows that the credit period allowed to the AEs is comparable with credit period of non-AEs in respect of similar goods. To compare credit period in respect of finished goods with the credit period in respect of semi-finished goods, is, therefore, somewhat fallacious in approach and untenable in law. In our considered view, merely because there is a delay in realization of debts cannot be reason enough to make an addition as long as such a delay is peculiar to the transactions with AEs. The adjustment before us is an adjustment to arrive at an arm's length price and unless there is something, more than sweeping generalizations as implicit in the arguments before us, to at least indicate that such a delay in realization of deb....