TaxTMI 
TaxTMI 
2017 (10) TMI 1016
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....rictly controlled by the State Government. Previously, the retail dealers like the assessee used to deposit the cost price, excise duty, bottling charges etc in the Treasury against Form TR-7 in cash for getting supplies from the wholesale Licensee. Subsequently, the Excise Department by a notification dated 29.8.2005 changed the procedure. As per the revised procedure prescribed by the Excise Department, for lifting country spirit, the assessee , who is a retail vendor, was required to make the entire payment consisting of cost of the stock in trade, Excise duty and bottling charges etc only to the wholesale licensee appointed by the State Government. Following the revised procedure, the assessee made payments to M/s IFB Agro Industries Ltd towards purchases of country liquor. Against the aforesaid purchases, the assessee made payments in cash by depositing money directly to the bank account of the aforesaid company. The ld AO observed that the payment for purchase was exceeding Rs. 20,000/- resulting in violation of provisions of section 40A(3) of the Act and accordingly proceeded to disallow a sum of Rs. 67,12,562/- in the assessment. This disallowance was deleted by the ld CITA....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....e sake of better understanding of the facts :- "In exercise of the power conferred by section 85 and section 86 of the Bengal Excise Act, 1909 (Ben. Act V of 1909) and in supersession of the rules published with this Department Notification No. 122-EX/O/1R-1/2000 dated 23.2.2000, as subsequently amended, the Governor is pleased hereby to make the following rules regulating the issue and removal of country spirit on payment of duty in labelled and capsuled bottles from country spirit bottling plants and in bulk from warehouses by the licensed wholesale vendors of the same for the purpose of selling country spirit by wholesale:-- Rules 1. Short Title and commencement.--(1) These rules may be called the West Bengal Excise (Supply of Country Spirit on Payment of Duty) Rules, 2005. (2) These rules shall come into force from 19th October, 2005. 2. Definitions.--(1) In these rules, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context-- (i) "Commissioner" means the Excise Commissioner; (ii) "requisition" means the requisition submitted by the authorized representative of licensed wholesale vendor of country spirit in Form II appended to these rules; (iii) "retail ve....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... to the representative of the wholesale licensee, through Excise Officer-in-Charge of the warehouse, a demand for issue of country spirit in Form I appended to these rules in duplicate. The duplicate copy shall be kept in the custody of the Excise Officer-in-Charge for his official record. (2) No retail vendor of country spirit shall deposit duty direct into the local treasury for issue of country spirit to be taken by him from the warehouse concerned. Duty, cost price, bottling charge, if there be any, at the prescribed rate and other imposition, as may be prescribed by law, shall be paid by the retail vendor to the credit of the wholesale licensee concerned. (3) The authorized representative of the wholesale licensee shall realize the necessary amount of duty, cost price and bottling charge, if there be any, at the prescribed rate and such other imposition, as may be prescribed by law, from the retail vendor to whom country spirit is to be issued from the concerned warehouse. The authorized representative as above shall then submit requisition in duplicate in Form II appended to these rules to the Excise Officer-in-Charge of the warehouse separately for each of the retail v....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....ction 40A(3) of the Act. 15. We find that the following facts are undisputed and indisputable:- (a) The transactions made by the assessee is genuine. (b) The identity of the receiver (wholesale licensee) is established beyond doubt. (c) The payment is made in the bank account of the seller (wholesale licensee). We hold that since the genuinity of the payments made to the M/s Asansol Bottling & Packaging Co. Pvt. Ltd (wholesale licensee) is not doubted by the revenue, the provisions of section 40A(3) could not be made applicable to the facts of the instant case. It is observed that the assessee had taken enough precautions from its side to ensure that the payee also don't escape from the ambit of taxation on these receipts by directly depositing the cash in the bank account of the payee. Moreover, the regulations of the West Bengal Government pursuant to notification from its Excise Department dated 29.8.2005 also mandates the payment to be made by way of direct deposit into the bank account of the wholesale licensee. This fact is also not disputed by the revenue. 16. It will be pertinent to go into the intention behind introduction of provisions of section 40A....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....A(3) and rule 6DD that they are intended to regulate business transactions and to prevent the use of unaccounted money or reduce the chances to use black money for business transactions." CIT vs CPL Tannery reported in (2009) 318 ITR 179 (Cal) The contention of the assessee that he purchased goods from suppliers who are producers of hides and skins, has not been refuted either by the AO or by the CITA. The second contention of the assessee that owing to business expediency, obligation and exigency, the assessee had to make cash payment for purchase of goods so essential for carrying on of his business, was also not disputed by the AO. The genuinity of transactions, rate of gross profit or the fact that the bonafide of the assessee that payments are made to M/s IFB Agro Industries Ltd for purchase of country spirit are also neither doubted nor disputed by the AO. On the basis of these facts it is not justified on the part of the AO to disallow 20% of the payments made u/s 40A(3) in the process of assessment. We, therefore, delete the addition of Rs. 17,90,571/- and ground no.1 is decided in favour of the assessee. CIT vs Crescent Export Syndicate in ITA No. 202 of 2008 dated....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....escribed limit - Assessee submitted that he made payment in cash because seller insisted on that and also gave incentives and discounts - Further, seller also issued certificate in support of this - Whether since assessee had placed proof of payment of consideration for its transaction to seller, and later admitted payment and there was no doubt about genuineness of payment, no disallowance could be made under section 40A(3) - Held, yes [Para 23] [In favour of the assessee]" CIT vs Smt. Shelly Passi reported in (2013) 350 ITR 227 (P&H) In this case the court upheld the view of the tribunal in not applying section 40A(3) of the Act to the cash payments when ultimately, such amounts were deposited in the bank by the payee. 18. We are not inclined to ignore the intention of the provisions of section 40A(3) of the Act by giving a plain reading of the same as argued by the ld DR. We find that the disallowance of the entire cash purchases results in abnormal trading profit for the assessee which it could never earn. We find a purposive construction should be resorted to while applying the provisions of the Act. Hence it would be more relevant to get into the intention of the legi....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....under the Income Tax Act that before invoking the provisions of section 40A(3) in the light of Rule 6DD as clarified by the Circular of the CBDT that whether the failure on the part of the assessee in adhering to requirement of provisions of section 40A(3) has any such nexus which defeats the object of provision so as to invite such a consequence. We hold that the purpose of section 40A(3) is only preventive and to check evasion of tax and flow of unaccounted money or to check transactions which are not genuine and may be put as camouflage to evade tax by showing fictitious or false transactions. Admittedly, this is not the case in the facts of the assessee herein. The assessee had directly deposited cash in the bank account of the supplier M/s Asansol Bottling & Packaging Co. Pvt Ltd which fact is also accepted by the ld AO and mandated by the Notification dated 29.8.2005 issued by the Excise Department , Government of West Bengal. It is also pertinent to note that the Hon'ble Rajasthan High Court in the case of Smt.Harshila Chordia vs ITOreported in (2008) 298 ITR 349 (Raj) had held that the exceptions contained in Rule 6DD of Income Tax Rules are not exhaustive and that the ....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
.... 2 of the assessment order. A perusal of the Kolkata Gazette Tuesday 20th Sept 2005 shows that the Government of West Bengal, Department of Excise has issued a notification, wherein the warehouse has been identified to mean the warehouse for supply of country spirit to the retail vendors, established at convenient places by the Commissioner at the expense of the State Government, or at the expense of a person to whom the exclusive privilege of supplying or selling country spirit by wholesale has been granted u/s 22 of the Act of a licensed wholesale vendor of country spirit. Further, it has been specifically identified that the authorised representative of the wholesale licensee shall realize the necessary amount of duty, cost price and bottling charge, if there be any, at the prescribed rate and such other imposition, as may be prescribed by law, from the retail vendor to whom the country spirit is to be issued from the concerned warehouse. It is also specifically mentioned in section (2) of the said notification that no retail vendor of country spirit shall deposit duty direct into the local treasury for issue of country spirit to be taken by him from the warehouse concerned whic....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....2005 with privilege granted u/s 22 of The Bengal Excise Act, 1909. At this juncture, it would be relevant to go into the definition of warehouse as provided under the State Excise Rules 2005 as below:- "Warehouse" , under Rule 2(vii) of the W.B.Excise Rules 2005 , means the warehouse for supply of country spirit to retail vendors, established at convenient places by the Commissioner at the expense of the State Government, or at the expense of a person to whom the exclusive privilege of supplying or selling country spirit by wholesale has been granted under section 22 of the Act, or of a licensed wholesale vendor of country spirit. The above definition makes it clear that the 'warehouse' referred to under the State Excise Rules is under the direct control and authority of the Commissioner of State Excise because it is established by the Commissioner of State Excise and as such is a State Government establishment. It is also pertinent to note that the expenditure in relation to such warehouse is borne by the State Government or by the licensee to whom the exclusive privilege is granted u/s 22 of the Bengal Excise Act, 1909. Hence there could be no doubt that the warehou....
X X X X Extracts X X X X
X X X X Extracts X X X X
....payments for purchase of country spirit by depositing cash directly into the bank account of M/s ABPL as per Rule 6(2) of the Excise Rules 2005 , it has to be construed as payment made to the State Government authority and accordingly falls under the exception provided in Rule 6DD(b) of the IT Rules. 22. It is not in dispute that M/s Asansol Bottling & Packaging Co. Pvt Ltd have been granted licence to act as a wholesaler for supply of country liquor to the retail vendor as per the regulations of the Excise Department , Government of West Bengal. At the cost of repetition, we would like to state that the said regulation mandated the payments to be made directly into the bank account of the said wholesale licensee by the retail vendor (i.e assessee herein) for strict and effective regulation of the country liquor and for prevention of spurious stocks and black marketing transactions from the same. Hence it could be safely concluded that the said wholesale licensee had acted at the instance of the State Government. Once this is so, then the said wholesale licensee could be construed as an agent of the State Government. For the sake of convenience, the relevant rule is reproduced h....