HC ruled in favor of the assessee on multiple taxation issues...

HC ruled in favor of the assessee on multiple taxation issues affecting general insurance companies. Regarding profit on sale of investments, the court held that prior to April 1, 2011, no provision required revenue to disallow deduction of investment losses, following SC precedent in United India Insurance Co. On MAT provisions under Section 115JB, HC determined insurance companies prepare accounts per IRDA guidelines, not Companies Act Schedule VI, making MAT inapplicable. Commission on reinsurance was treated as discount on premium rather than taxable commission. TDS disallowance under Section 40(a)(i) for overseas surveyor payments was rejected as payments were not taxable in India absent permanent establishment. Depreciation on UPS was allowed at 60% rate. Section 14A disallowance was ruled inapplicable to insurance business computation scheme. Reinsurance premium disallowance under Section 40(a)(i) was rejected based on substantive analysis and rule of consistency, as revenue had accepted assessee's position in subsequent years.

---