detention of goods

[VIGNESH]

sir , goods were moved to kerala from Tamilnadu , Invoice was missed to handover to driver, but Eway bill generated. Penalty was levied and client paid, can we prefer appeal now ? is there is any cases in favour of assessee? kindly guide

[KASTURI SETHI]

Invoice was issued but did not accompany the goods. This is a very serious lapse. It cannot be considered as a procedural lapse. You can file appeal, if not hit by time limitation.

Has penalty been paid under protest ?

Pl. confirm.

[KASTURI SETHI]

If the assessee's records are neat and clean ( you can prove that it was a bona fide mistake and it is first mistake) and such mistake has not been committed since implementation of GST, the remote possibility of relief from the appellate authority cannot be ruled out.

[Shilpi Jain]

If it was a mere invoice missed to be handed over to the driver and if u can prove that the invoice was already issued there should not be any liability. It should be only a procedural lapse.

[Ganeshan Kalyani]

I agree with the views of both the experts. If you are liable to follow E-invoice procedure then you can prove that the tax invoice was generated and then IRN (Invoice Reference Number) was obtained from IRP (Invoice Registration Portal) before vehicle was released.

AI Summary

Company Faces GST Penalty for Missing Invoice During Transport; Experts Discuss Appeal Possibilities and Procedural Lapse Defense A company faced a penalty under GST regulations when goods transported from Tamil Nadu to Kerala lacked an accompanying invoice, although an Eway bill was generated. The company inquired about the possibility of appealing the penalty, seeking guidance on favorable precedents. One expert emphasized the seriousness of the lapse, suggesting an appeal might be possible if within the time limit and if the penalty was paid under protest. Another expert noted that if the records are clean and it was a first-time mistake, relief might be possible. Others suggested proving the invoice was issued could classify the issue as a procedural lapse.