Functional connection with manufacture supports Modvat credit for a panel cooler integrated with CNC machinery.

A panel cooler fitted to a CNC machine and used for temperature control was treated as capital goods because it performed a specific function essential to the machine's proper operation in manufacture. An item that works along with the main machinery and has a functional connection with the production process was regarded as part of the plant used for manufacture, so Modvat credit could not be denied. The Revenue's challenge was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether a panel cooler attached to a CNC machine and used for temperature control qualifies as capital goods for the purpose of Modvat credit.

Analysis: The panel cooler was found to be fitted to the CNC machine and to serve a specific function essential for regulating temperature so that the machine could operate properly in producing the final product. An item functioning along with the main machinery for manufacture was treated as part of the main machinery itself. The settled principle applied was that Modvat credit cannot be denied where the item has a functional connection with the production process and operates as part of the plant used for manufacture.

Conclusion: The panel cooler was held to be capital goods eligible for Modvat credit, and the Revenue's challenge was rejected.

---