Share transfer requires communicated acceptance and statutory compliance; defective instruments and missing certificates bar rectification of the register.

A transfer of shares was treated as incomplete where the alleged offer to sell had not been accepted and that acceptance had not been communicated to the original offerors; a communication to one person did not bind others who had made the proposal in their own names. The attempted transfer also failed where the transfer deeds were not duly stamped and properly completed, and the share certificates were not produced as required by the Companies Act and the articles. On those facts, rectification of the register could not be ordered for the defective transfers, and only the remaining two shares were registrable in favour of the petitioner on payment of the amount fixed by the Court.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether the shares held by Gurdial and Vidya Vati and two of the shares held by Ram Dial had been validly transferred to the petitioner so as to justify rectification of the register; (ii) whether the absence of a duly stamped and properly completed transfer instrument and the non-production of share certificates barred registration of the transfers.

Issue (i): Whether the shares held by Gurdial and Vidya Vati and two of the shares held by Ram Dial had been validly transferred to the petitioner so as to justify rectification of the register.

Analysis: The letters and transfer deeds executed by Gurdial and Vidya Vati were treated as only an offer to sell on terms to be fixed by the Railway Administration, not as a concluded sale. A contract for sale of shares, being a contract of sale of goods, required acceptance of the offer and communication of that acceptance to the offerors. Acceptance communicated only to Ram Dial did not bind Gurdial or Vidya Vati, since they had made the proposal in their own names and Ram Dial had no authority to act for them. Their subsequent letters amounted to revocation, and the proposal also lapsed by passage of reasonable time without communicated acceptance. As to the two shares retained by Ram Dial, the petitioner failed to establish delivery of the scrips and the shares remained subject to Mrs. Perry's asserted lien and pledge.

Conclusion: The alleged transfer of the shares held by Gurdial and Vidya Vati was not completed, and the petition failed in respect of those shares. The claim also failed in respect of Ram Dial's shares Nos. 39 and 40.

Issue (ii): Whether the absence of a duly stamped and properly completed transfer instrument and the non-production of share certificates barred registration of the transfers.

Analysis: The transfer deeds executed by Gurdial and Vidya Vati were not properly effective because the adhesive stamps on them had not been cancelled as required, rendering those instruments unstamped for legal purposes. Under the Companies Act, a company could not register a transfer unless a proper instrument of transfer, duly stamped and executed by or on behalf of transferor and transferee, together with the share certificate, was delivered. The statutory requirement was mandatory, and rectification could not be ordered so as to compel registration in violation of the statute. In addition, the share certificates for Ram Dial's shares Nos. 39 and 40 were not produced, and the company's articles also required production of the certificate before registration.

Conclusion: Registration was barred for the shares covered by the defective or incomplete transfer documents, and rectification was unavailable for those shares. Only the remaining two shares of Ram Dial could be registered in favour of the petitioner on payment of the amount fixed by the Court.

Final Conclusion: The petition succeeded only to a limited extent, resulting in transfer and registration of two shares in favour of the petitioner, while the remaining claims for rectification were rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: A transfer of shares is not complete unless there is a communicated acceptance of the offer and compliance with the statutory requirements of a duly stamped and properly executed transfer instrument accompanied by the required share certificate; absent such compliance, rectification of the register cannot be ordered.

---