Shareholder locus standi is limited in challenging company property sales; proper relief lies through the Companies Act remedy.
A shareholder cannot, in his own name, seek to set aside a court sale of company property under Order XXI, Rule 90 CPC merely by alleging fraud, collusion, or mismanagement in the company's affairs. The property belongs to the company as a separate legal person, so a shareholder's interest in its fortunes does not create direct locus standi to challenge the sale as if the property were personally his. Where the grievance is that the company is being managed prejudicially, oppressively, or in fraud of the company, the proper course is to invoke the statutory remedy under section 153-C of the Indian Companies Act on behalf of the company.
Issues: Whether a shareholder of a company has locus standi to seek setting aside of a court sale of company property under Order XXI, Rule 90 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and whether allegations of fraud or collusion in the management of the company entitle such shareholder to maintain the application in his own name.
Analysis: A shareholder is interested in the fortunes of the company, but the property belongs to the company as a separate legal person and not to the individual shareholder. A complaint that company property has been mismanaged or fraudulently disposed of does not, by itself, give every shareholder a direct right to challenge the transaction in his own name. Where the grievance is that the affairs of the company are being conducted prejudicially, oppressively, or in fraud of the company, the law provides a specific remedy under section 153-C of the Indian Companies Act. The shareholder may seek appropriate relief on behalf of the company through that statutory mechanism, but cannot, on that footing alone, invoke Order XXI, Rule 90 as if the property were his own.
Conclusion: The shareholder had no locus standi to maintain the application to set aside the sale in his own name, and the appropriate remedy lay under section 153-C of the Indian Companies Act.
TaxTMI 
AI Drafter ✕
TaxTMI 
