Registration of charges over immovable property: local registration required in addition to company filings, affecting charge priority.

Debentures that create a charge, including floating or contingent charges, over immovable property fall within the scope of non-testamentary instruments affecting rights in immovable property and therefore require registration in the local registry where the property is situated under the Registration Act; registration under company law alone does not substitute for local, property-specific registration or the notice it provides to local third parties. The legal effect is that failure to register such a charge locally prevents the debenture-holder from asserting a first charge on the immovable property in question, and the appellants' challenge to priority succeeds.

---

---

Issues: Whether debentures issued by a company which create a charge (floating or contingent) over immovable property must be registered under the Registration Act, 1908 in addition to registration under the Companies Act, 1913.

Analysis: The Court examined the scope and purposes of registration under the Companies Act (including Sections 109, 109A and 110) and the Registration Act (including Section 17(1), Section 21, Section 28 and Section 49). While registration under the Companies Act notifies persons dealing with the company of the existence and extent of company charges generally, it does not provide local, property-specific information in the district where immovable property is situate. The Registration Act requires registration of non-testamentary instruments which create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish rights or interests in immovable property and mandates sufficient property description for local registration. A debenture that on its face creates a floating charge over the whole of a company's property limits the company's rights in immovable property contingently and thus falls within Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act. The Court rejected the argument that absence of specific property description in such debentures prevents local registration, holding that where a charge affecting immovable property exists registration in the appropriate local registry is required to give effective notice to local persons dealing with land.

Conclusion: A debenture which creates a charge, whether floating or contingent, over immovable property must be registered under the Registration Act, 1908 in the appropriate local registry in addition to any registration under the Companies Act, 1913. Accordingly, the debenture-holder in this case does not have a first charge on the immovable property and the appeal is allowed in favour of the appellants.

---