Synonymous product descriptions supported waiver of pre-deposit and stay of recovery in a pending appeal.

Interim relief was granted in a stay proceeding where the final product was described as Local Control Station and the clearance documents also used Push Button Station as an interchangeable description. The Tribunal treated the two expressions as synonymous, noted that the Department had raised no objection to that usage, and found that the appellant had shown a sufficient prima facie case for relief. On that basis, pre-deposit of the duty demand and penalty was dispensed with and recovery was stayed pending disposal of the appeal.

---

---

Issues: Whether the condition of pre-deposit of duty demand and penalty should be dispensed with in a stay petition where the final product was declared under one description and clearance documents also used another description treated as synonymous.

Analysis: The declaration on record showed the final product as Local Control Station, while the clearance documents sometimes described it as Push Button Station and sometimes as Local Control Station. The Tribunal accepted that the two expressions were used synonymously in the documents and noted that the Department had raised no objection to that usage. On that basis, the appellant's claim that the declared product covered the goods in question was found to have sufficient force for interim relief.

Conclusion: The condition of pre-deposit of the entire duty demand and penalty was dispensed with and recovery was stayed during the pendency of the appeal.

Final Conclusion: Interim relief was granted by waiving pre-deposit and protecting the appellant from recovery pending the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the record shows that two descriptions of the same final product were used interchangeably and without departmental objection, pre-deposit may be waived in a stay proceeding if that supports a prima facie case against denial of credit.

---