Trade discount before removal remains deductible, including stockist-only discounts, bonus supplies, breakage adjustments and receivables interest.

Under excise valuation principles, a trade discount known before removal and granted in the course of trade is deductible from assessable value, even if confined to stockists rather than all buyers. On that basis, the additional discount or free bonus claimed was also treated as an admissible deduction because uniformity was not required once the discount was established before clearance. Free supply relating to breakages was likewise accepted as a permissible trade adjustment, and interest on receivables was excluded from valuation in line with the governing precedent. The overall treatment favoured deduction of the principal valuation components claimed by the assessee.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether special discount allowed only to stockists was deductible from assessable value; (ii) whether additional discount/free bonus was deductible; (iii) whether free supply on account of breakages was deductible; and (iv) whether interest on receivables was deductible.

Issue (i): whether special discount allowed only to stockists was deductible from assessable value.

Analysis: Trade discount known prior to removal of goods and given in the course of trade is an allowable deduction. The fact that the discount is confined to stockists does not, by itself, disentitle the deduction, where it is not shown that the discount was unknown at the time of removal.

Conclusion: The special discount was deductible and the Revenue's challenge on this ground failed.

Issue (ii): whether additional discount/free bonus was deductible.

Analysis: A trade discount need not satisfy a requirement of uniformity, and a discount known before removal of goods remains admissible. On that footing, the additional discount/free bonus claimed by the assessee fell within the permissible deduction.

Conclusion: The additional discount/free bonus was deductible and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (iii): whether free supply on account of breakages was deductible.

Analysis: Deduction for breakage-related free supply is allowable where the commercial practice is recognised as a permissible trade adjustment and the matter is covered by the applicable precedent relied upon.

Conclusion: The free supply on account of breakages was deductible and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (iv): whether interest on receivables was deductible.

Analysis: Interest on receivables is not includible in assessable value where the governing precedent permits exclusion of such component from valuation.

Conclusion: Interest on receivables was deductible and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Final Conclusion: The valuation dispute under Section 4 of the Central Excise Act was resolved by allowing the principal trade-discount related deductions claimed by the assessee, while the remaining claims did not alter the overall partial success of the parties.

Ratio Decidendi: A trade discount, if known before removal of goods and granted in the course of trade, is deductible from assessable value, and the availability of such deduction is not defeated merely because the discount is confined to stockists or is not uniform across buyers.

---