Rebate on excess excise duty paid outside assessable value remains admissible where export conditions are met.

Duty paid on freight, insurance, commission and discount amounts outside assessable value under section 4 could not be retained by the Department. The Tribunal followed its earlier view that excess duty paid on export, lacking any legal basis for appropriation, remained eligible for rebate or refund where statutory export conditions were satisfied. The denial of rebate was therefore erroneous, and the appellate grant of rebate on the full duty paid was upheld.

---

---

Issues: Whether rebate could be denied in respect of duty paid on amounts outside the assessable value under section 4, and whether the excess duty paid at the time of export was refundable or rebateable under the governing excise framework.

Analysis: The Tribunal followed its earlier decision on the same legal question and held that duty paid on freight, insurance, commission and discount, being amounts outside the scope of assessable value under section 4, could not be retained by the Department. The excess duty was not shown to have any legal basis for appropriation and the denial of rebate by the adjudicating authority was found to be erroneous. The appellate authority had rightly granted rebate on the full duty paid at export, subject to the stipulated conditions.

Conclusion: The rebate claim was held to be admissible and the Department's challenge was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The order granting rebate to the exporter was affirmed and the revenue appeal failed.

Ratio Decidendi: Duty paid on amounts not forming part of the assessable value cannot be appropriated by the Department and remains eligible for rebate or refund where the statutory export conditions are satisfied.

---