Modvat credit remains usable after product reclassification where duty-paid inputs feed the dutiable final product.

Modvat credit on duty-paid plastic granules used in the manufacture of dutiable HDPE sacks/bags remained utilisable after reclassification of the product, because the scheme does not require a strict one-to-one correlation between each input and the final product. Credit could not be denied merely because the inputs had earlier been used in producing tapes/strips, and procedural objections were required to yield to substantive entitlement where the inputs supported manufacture of the dutiable final goods.

---

---

Issues: Whether the appellant was entitled to utilise the Modvat credit balance lying in RG 23A Part II for payment of duty on HDPE sacks/bags after the reclassification of the product, and whether such credit could be denied on the ground that it related to inputs already used in the manufacture of earlier classified tapes/strips.

Analysis: The dispute arose from a change in classification under Section 37B, after which the appellant's products, including tapes and sacks, fell under the same tariff chapter. The credit in question had been earned under the Modvat scheme on duty-paid plastic granules used in the continuous manufacture of the intermediate and final products. The governing principle applied was that Modvat credit does not require strict one-to-one correlation between a particular input and the final product, so long as the inputs are used in the dutiable final product. The Tribunal also followed its earlier view that credit utilisation should not be denied merely on procedural grounds where the substance of entitlement is established.

Conclusion: The appellant was entitled to the benefit of the credit balance for duty payment on HDPE sacks/bags, and the refusal to allow such utilisation was unsustainable.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded and the order denying utilisation of the credit balance was set aside with consequential relief.

Ratio Decidendi: Where duty-paid inputs are used in the manufacture of dutiable final products under the Modvat scheme, credit cannot be denied merely because of reclassification or the absence of strict one-to-one correlation, and procedural objections must yield to substantive entitlement.

---