Modvat credit on pre-registration invoices upheld where later registration and substantive compliance satisfied the transitional requirements.

Modvat credit could not be denied merely because invoices were issued by a dealer before registration was obtained, where the dealer was otherwise eligible to issue such invoices and later secured the requisite registration. The governing notifications and Board circular permitted acceptance of prescribed invoices during the transitional period, provided they contained the required particulars and the substantive Modvat conditions were met. As the inputs were received and used in the final product without dispute, the duty-paying documents were treated as valid in the facts of the case, and the credit was sustained in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit could be denied on invoices issued by a dealer who had not been registered under the relevant rule at the time of issue but was later registered, in the light of the departmental notifications and the Board circular.

Analysis: The dispute turned on the validity of invoices issued by a dealer eligible to issue such invoices under the notifications governing the period, and on the effect of the Board's circular dealing with transitional difficulties after the amendment of the Modvat provisions. The circular clarified that invoices issued by the specified categories of persons could be recognised if they contained the prescribed particulars and the person had obtained registration under the relevant rule, and further permitted acceptance of such documents up to the stipulated cut-off date. The record also showed no dispute as to receipt and use of the inputs in the final product, indicating substantive compliance with the Modvat requirements.

Conclusion: Modvat credit could not be denied on the disputed invoices, and the credit was rightly allowed in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The departmental challenge failed and the allowance of Modvat credit was sustained on the footing that the invoices were acceptable duty-paying documents in the facts of the case.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the person issuing the invoice was otherwise eligible to issue such invoices and subsequently obtained the requisite registration, and the substantive requirements of Modvat credit were satisfied, credit could not be denied merely for the timing of registration when the governing circular and transitional provisions permitted acceptance of the documents.

---