Captive manufacture exemption for replacement parts applied to glass funnels and guides used in machinery maintenance.

Captively manufactured glass funnels and guides used in the spinning department to replace broken machine parts fell within the scope of Notification No. 281/86 dated 24-4-1986. Repair and maintenance was treated as covering not only direct repair of parts in use, but also replacement of worn or broken parts with goods made in the factory for that purpose. Applying the same reasoning as an earlier Tribunal decision on identical goods, the exemption was held admissible and the claim succeeded in favour of the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the benefit of Notification No. 281/86 dated 24-4-1986 was available to glass Funnels and Guides manufactured captively and used in the spinning department for replacing broken parts of machinery.

Analysis: The goods were manufactured in the factory and were used in the spinning department to replace broken Funnels and Guides. Repair and maintenance was held to cover not only direct repair of parts in use but also the goods used for replacement of worn or broken parts. The same goods had already been considered in an earlier Tribunal decision, and the same reasoning was applied.

Conclusion: The benefit of Notification No. 281/86 dated 24-4-1986 was admissible, and the issue was decided in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded on the exemption claim for the captively manufactured Funnels and Guides used in maintenance of machinery.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods manufactured captively and used for replacement of broken machine parts in repair and maintenance activity fall within the scope of the exemption notification.

---