Tungsten carbide burnishing balls classified under sub-heading 8101.00, not as tool parts under Heading 82.09.

Burnishing balls made of tungsten carbide, used for polishing and smoothening tube interiors, were held classifiable under sub-heading 8101.00. Classification under Heading 82.09 was rejected because the HSN notes cover tool parts such as plates, sticks and tips, while these balls are independent articles and not mounting materials or tool components. The article's composition and functional description supported treatment as tungsten carbide goods, and the alternative tariff headings suggested by the Department were not supported by the technical nature of the product.

---

---

Issues: Whether burnishing balls manufactured out of tungsten carbide were classifiable under sub-heading 8101.00 or under Heading 82.09 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.

Analysis: The goods were described as spherical burnishing balls used for polishing and smoothening the inner surface of tubes. The classification under Heading 82.09 was rejected because the explanatory notes to the Harmonised System of Nomenclature referred to plates, sticks, tips and similar parts for tools, whereas burnishing balls are independent articles and not tool parts or mounting materials. The material composition and use showed them to be articles predominantly of tungsten carbide, and the earlier departmental classification had been changed without cogent reasons. Alternative suggestions of classification under other tariff sub-headings were not supported by the technical description of the goods.

Conclusion: Burnishing balls were rightly classifiable under sub-heading 8101.00 and not under Heading 82.09 or the alternative headings suggested by the Department.

---