Licit cultivation certificates defeat confiscation of imported poppy seeds when no fraud is proved and a general circular cannot override the notification.

A customs import notification governing poppy seeds required proof of licit cultivation and certification by the concerned foreign government. Contemporaneous certificates from Pakistani authorities certifying lawful origin and cultivation were accepted because the department produced no evidence that they were forged or fraudulent. A general INCB circular could not override the governing notification or create a default prohibition on goods from Pakistan. On that basis, confiscation and penalty were not sustainable, and the importer obtained consequential relief.

---

---

Issues: Whether the confiscation of imported poppy seeds and the consequent penalty were sustainable when the importer produced certificates showing licit cultivation and lawful origin, and the only adverse basis was an INCB circular.

Analysis: The import was governed by Notification No. 25 (RE/98) of the DGFT, which required that poppy seeds be grown licitly and certified by the concerned government. The notification did not treat goods from Pakistan as illicit by default and did not incorporate any prohibition based on an INCB circular. The importer produced contemporaneous certificates from independent Pakistani authorities, including the Chamber of Commerce, the Plant Quarantine Department, and the Export Promotion Bureau, each certifying Pakistani origin and licit cultivation. No material was shown to establish that these certificates were forged or fraudulent. The circular relied upon by the customs authorities related to an earlier period and did not override the governing import notification.

Conclusion: The confiscation and penalty were not sustainable, and the importer succeeded on the issue.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order was set aside and the appeal was allowed with consequential relief.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the applicable import notification requires certification of licit cultivation by the concerned foreign government, duly produced contemporaneous certificates cannot be disregarded merely on the basis of a general circular unless the department proves them to be false or the notification itself incorporates such a prohibition.

---