Modvat credit cannot be denied for departmental delay in issuing acknowledgement; it relates back to the declaration date.

Under the Modvat scheme, credit on inputs received after filing the declaration but before receipt of the departmental acknowledgement should not be denied where the assessee had already complied with the filing requirement and the delay in acknowledgement was attributable to the department. The analysis states that a harmonious construction of Rule 57G requires the acknowledgement to relate back to the date of filing of the declaration, so procedural delay by the authorities does not prejudice entitlement to credit. It also notes that Rule 57H supports this alternative basis for entitlement. The stated conclusion is that denial of Modvat credit was unjustified and the assessee succeeded.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit on inputs received after filing of the declaration but before receipt of the dated acknowledgement could be denied, and whether the acknowledgement related back to the date of filing of the declaration.

Analysis: The declaration under Rule 57G had been filed before the inputs were received, and the credit was taken only after the acknowledgement was received. The delay in issuing acknowledgement by the departmental authority was not attributable to the assessee. A harmonious construction of the Modvat scheme required that procedural delay on the part of the department should not prejudice the assessee. The view that credit could not be denied in such circumstances was also consistent with the scheme of Rule 57H, which was relied upon as an alternative basis for entitlement.

Conclusion: The acknowledgement related back to the date of filing of the declaration, and the denial of Modvat credit was not justified. The appeal was allowed in favour of the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a declaration under the Modvat scheme is filed before receipt of inputs and the departmental acknowledgement is delayed, the acknowledgement relates back to the date of filing, and the assessee cannot be denied credit merely because of departmental delay.

---