Auto-combusted molasses residue cannot be taxed as molasses; excise classification, duty demand, and collection were set aside

Solid mass formed by auto-combustion of molasses was held not to be molasses itself, but a distinct product arising from a natural phenomenon. On that basis, it could not be classified and charged to excise duty as molasses merely because it originated from molasses, and the Department could not require a classification list or duty payment on clearance on that footing. The earlier remission under Rule 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 was also said to be undermined by such treatment. Duty collected on clearance of the solid mass was refundable to the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether the solid mass formed by auto-combustion of molasses could still be treated as molasses for excise classification and duty purposes, and whether the assessee was required to file a classification list and pay duty on its clearance.

Analysis: The solid product was not molasses as such but only the result of auto-combustion of molasses, a natural phenomenon. Once the lower appellate authority had itself accepted that the product was not manufactured molasses, the Department could not insist on treating it as molasses or compel classification and duty payment on that basis. Such a course would also defeat the earlier remission granted under Rule 49 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944.

Conclusion: The product could not be treated as molasses for duty purposes, the assessee was not required to file a classification list, and the duty collected on clearance of the solid mass was refundable to the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The assessee succeeded in full on the excise classification and duty liability issue, and the Department's demand was set aside.

Ratio Decidendi: A product arising only from auto-combustion of molasses, and not amounting to molasses itself, cannot be classified and taxed as molasses merely because it originated from molasses.

---