Differential Modvat credit may be taken later on the same duty-paying documents when the balance is admissible and timely claimed.

Differential Modvat credit under Rule 57B may be availed later on the same duty-paying documents where the initial credit is undisputed and the statutory scheme does not bar staggered availment. The earlier Tribunal view treated subsequent claim of the balance credit as permissible in instalments, and rejected administrative inconvenience as a ground to deny it. A six-month period under Section 11B was treated as a reasonable benchmark for such later availment, and the same documents supported the additional credit claim. On that basis, staggered availment of admissible credit was upheld and the departmental challenge failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether differential Modvat credit under Rule 57B could be taken subsequent to the initial credit on the same duty-paying documents, and whether such staggered availment was barred when taken within a reasonable time.

Analysis: The credit originally taken on inputs from small scale manufacturers was not disputed, and the later claim was only for the differential credit becoming admissible under Rule 57B. The earlier Tribunal view, consistently followed, was that nothing in the scheme prohibited the assessee from taking the balance credit later in instalments. The objection of administrative inconvenience was not accepted, and the period of six months under Section 11B was treated as a reasonable benchmark for such subsequent availment. In the present case, the show cause notice itself was issued within six months of the original credit, and the same duty-paying documents supported the additional credit claim.

Conclusion: The differential Modvat credit was correctly allowed and the departmental appeal failed.

Final Conclusion: The order allowing staggered availment of admissible Modvat credit was upheld, and the department's challenge was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the entitlement to credit is undisputed and the statutory scheme does not prohibit later availment of the balance, differential Modvat credit may be taken within a reasonable time on the same duty-paying documents.

---