Furniture classification for iron and steel book shelves excludes exemption where the notification expressly bars such racks.

An iron and steel library system recognisable as a book shelf or book rack is treated as furniture for tariff purposes and is classifiable under CET sub-heading 9403.00 rather than as other articles of iron and steel under CET sub-heading 7326.90. The article notes that a precedent on factory-use metal items was distinguished because this product was suitable for use in a house or office. Where the exemption notification excludes book shelves and racks, such goods fall outside the exemption under Notification No. 80/90 and do not qualify for relief.

---

---

Issues: Whether the library system made of iron and steel was classifiable as furniture under CET sub-heading 9403.00 and, if so, whether it was excluded from exemption under Notification No. 80/90.

Analysis: The product was found to be a book shelf or book rack from which books could be taken out or placed from either side. Such an article is recognisable as furniture and is appropriately classifiable under CET sub-heading 9403.00 rather than as other articles of iron and steel under CET sub-heading 7326.90. The relied-upon precedent concerning factory-use metal items was distinguished because the present product was a book shelf or rack usable for convenience in a house or office. Book shelves and racks fall within the excluded category in the notification, and therefore do not qualify for the exemption.

Conclusion: The classification under CET sub-heading 9403.00 was upheld and the exemption claim under Notification No. 80/90 was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed, and the departmental classification and denial of exemption were sustained.

Ratio Decidendi: An article that is recognisable as a book shelf or rack is furniture for tariff purposes, and where the exemption notification excludes book shelves and racks, such goods are not entitled to the benefit of exemption.

---