Modvat credit eligibility for mould-making chemicals upheld despite a pending High Court reference

Resins and other chemicals used in producing moulds for motor vehicle parts were treated as eligible inputs for Modvat credit because prior reasoned Tribunal decisions, including a Larger Bench ruling, had already decided the issue on merits in favour of the assessee. A pending reference of a similar question to the High Court did not, by itself, weaken the binding force of that existing ratio. The chemicals were therefore regarded as qualifying inputs, and the Revenue's challenge was rejected.

---

---

Issues: Whether resins and other chemicals used in the production of moulds for motor vehicle parts were eligible inputs under the Modvat credit scheme.

Analysis: The issue was decided in favour of the assessee by prior Tribunal decisions, including a Larger Bench ruling that such chemicals qualified as inputs. The mere fact that a similar question had been referred to the High Court did not displace the binding effect of the Tribunal's ratio on the issue decided on merits.

Conclusion: The chemicals were held to be eligible inputs for Modvat credit, and the Revenue's appeal was rejected.

Final Conclusion: The impugned order recognising Modvat credit eligibility for the chemicals was affirmed and the Revenue's challenge failed.

Ratio Decidendi: A prior reasoned decision on the merits of an issue continues to govern unless displaced, and a pending reference of a similar question to the High Court does not by itself negate the binding force of that ratio.

---