Modvat credit on inputs destroyed during an integral manufacturing stage remained admissible despite fire before final product emergence.

Modvat credit was admissible where declared inputs had entered the manufacturing stream and were put to intended use before a fire destroyed the goods at the coating stage. The coating stage formed an integral part of manufacture, so the phrase "used in the manufacture of goods" covered the full conversion process from raw material to finished product. Rule 57F(3) supported credit on inputs intended for use, and Rule 57D protected credit in relation to waste arising during manufacture. Since credit on the quantity destroyed as such had already been reversed, denial of credit on the disputed inputs was unsustainable.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit was admissible on inputs that had entered the manufacturing process and were destroyed by fire at the coating stage before the final product emerged.

Analysis: The inputs had admittedly been declared for Modvat purposes and had been put to intended use within the manufacturing process. The fire occurred at the coating stage, which formed an integral part of manufacture, and the expression "used in the manufacture of goods" was held to cover the full process of conversion of raw material into finished goods. Rule 57F(3) was applied on the footing that credit could be utilised for inputs intended to be used, and Rule 57D supported protection of credit in relation to waste arising in the course of manufacture. The quantity destroyed as such had already been reversed, so the credit in dispute related to inputs that had actually entered the manufacturing stream.

Conclusion: Modvat credit was admissible, and the order denying relief was unsustainable.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded and the assessee retained the Modvat benefit on the disputed inputs.

Ratio Decidendi: Where inputs have been put to intended use in an integral stage of manufacture, destruction of the process goods by fire before emergence of the final product does not, by itself, require denial of Modvat credit.

---