Assessable value deductions for receivables, turnover discounts and transit breakages were upheld, but post-delivery expiry discounts were rejected.

Interest on receivables and turnover discount, whether given in cash or kind, were treated as deductible in determining assessable value, and deduction could not be denied merely because the discount was quantified only at the end of the relevant period. Deduction for breakages during transit was also accepted where the price collected already reflected the breakage value. By contrast, discount linked to expiry of goods in wholesalers' hands was not deductible, because the loss was borne by the wholesaler after delivery and any concession by the manufacturer was treated as sales promotion rather than a price-related allowance.

---

---

Issues: (i) whether interest on receivables and quantity or turnover discount in kind were deductible in determining assessable value; (ii) whether deduction was admissible on account of breakages during transit; (iii) whether discount attributable to expiry of goods in the hands of wholesalers was deductible.

Issue (i): whether interest on receivables and quantity or turnover discount in kind were deductible in determining assessable value.

Analysis: Interest on receivables was held deductible in determining assessable value. Turnover discount, whether in cash or in kind, was also held to be an admissible discount, and deduction could not be denied merely because the extent of the discount was ascertained only at the end of the relevant period.

Conclusion: Decided in favour of the assessee.

Issue (ii): whether deduction was admissible on account of breakages during transit.

Analysis: Where the appellant collected only the price less the value of breakages, deduction on this count was held to be legitimate and supported by tribunal precedent.

Conclusion: Decided in favour of the assessee.

Issue (iii): whether discount attributable to expiry of goods in the hands of wholesalers was deductible.

Analysis: The loss arising from expiry of goods after delivery to wholesalers was held to be the wholesalers' loss, not the manufacturer's loss. Any discount granted by the manufacturer on that account was treated as part of sales promotion activity and not as a deductible allowance.

Conclusion: Decided against the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded only to the extent of deductions for interest on receivables, turnover discount in kind, and breakages during transit, while the claim for interest on finished goods and expiry-date discount was not accepted.

Ratio Decidendi: Deductions affecting assessable value are allowable where they represent real trade-related abatements linked to the price at sale, but not where the alleged discount is a post-sale concession amounting to sales promotion or a loss borne by the buyer after delivery.

---