Coach parts classification: specially designed water tanks and sanitary wares were treated as integral railway coach components.

Water tanks and sanitary wares specially designed for exclusive fitment in railway coaches were classified as parts of coaches under Tariff Heading 8607. The reasoning was that the goods were made to railways' specific drawings, became integral to coach work, and were necessary for the coach to function. Heading 8312, which covers containers ordinarily used for transporting water, did not fit the nature of the goods, and the alternative headings for base metal and aluminium articles were also less appropriate. The items were therefore treated as coach parts under Chapter 86.

---

---

Issues: Whether water tanks and sanitary wares specially designed for fitment in railway coaches were classifiable under Tariff Heading 8607 as parts of coaches, or under alternative headings for containers and base metal articles.

Analysis: The goods were fabricated to the railways' specific design and drawings and were meant for exclusive fitment in railway coaches. Tariff Heading 8312 applies to containers ordinarily used for transport of water, which was not the nature of the goods in question. Chapter Note 2 to Chapter 86 treats coach work as covered by Chapter 86, and the term was understood in a broad functional sense to include work making the coach complete. Since the water tanks and sanitary wares became part of the coach itself and were necessary for its functioning, the alternative headings for base metal articles and aluminium articles were held to be less appropriate.

Conclusion: The items were correctly classifiable under Tariff Heading 8607 as parts of railway coaches, and not under Tariff Heading 8312, 7308 or 7613.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods specially designed for exclusive fitment in railway coaches, and becoming an integral part of coach work, are classifiable under Heading 8607 as coach parts.

---