Separate classification of imported spare parts upheld where invoices and records did not show they were integral machine components.

Imported spare parts and accessories of a direct reading carbon/sulphur determinator were assessed separately because they were shown as distinct items in the bills of entry and invoices with separate prices, and Customs had not altered the importer's declared classification. The record did not establish that the disputed goods were inseparable components of the main instrument, and some items were chemicals rather than integral machine parts. In the absence of supporting material such as a catalogue or other evidence proving that the goods formed part of the determinator, the importer could not displace its own declaration. Applying the relevant chapter note and accessories rules, the separate assessment was upheld and the refund claim failed.

---

---

Issues: Whether the imported items described as spare parts and accessories of a direct reading carbon/sulphur determinator were required to be classified along with the main instrument or separately assessed on their own merits.

Analysis: The items were shown separately in the bills of entry and invoices with separate prices, and no change was made by Customs to the classification declared by the importer. The record did not show that the disputed items formed an inseparable part of the determinator, and some items were in the nature of chemicals. In these circumstances, the importer could not displace its own declaration without producing material such as a catalogue or other evidence showing that the goods were parts of the main instrument. Applying the relevant chapter note and the accessories rules, separately imported and separately invoiced items were liable to assessment on their own merits.

Conclusion: The items were correctly classified and assessed separately, and the refund claim was not sustainable.

Final Conclusion: The appeal failed, and the refund rejection was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi: Where goods are imported and invoiced separately as distinct items, and the importer fails to prove that they are integral parts of the main machine, they may be classified and assessed independently under the applicable tariff notes and rules.

---