Tariff classification of bearing analyser BEA-52 turned on specific heading coverage, excluding the residuary entry.

BEA-52 bearing analyser was treated as an apparatus for checking the condition of bearings, using shock pulse analysis to assess lubrication, fatigue and surface damage. On that basis, it was found to fall within Heading 90.28(4) as the non-electric counterpart of an instrument covered by Heading 90.25, rather than within the residuary Heading 90.28(1), which applies only where no specific heading covers the goods. The classification adopted by the lower authority was set aside, and the refund claim succeeded on the tariff classification issue.

---

---

Issues: Whether the bearing analyser BEA-52 was correctly classifiable under the residuary Heading No. 90.28(1) of the Customs Tariff, or under Heading No. 90.28(4) as the non-electric counterpart of an instrument falling under Heading No. 90.25.

Analysis: The product literature showed that BEA-52 measures lubrication and mechanical condition in bearings, checks fatigue and surface damage, and operates by analysing shock pulse patterns. On that basis, the instrument was found to be an apparatus for checking the condition of bearings rather than a device for physical or chemical analysis or for measuring viscosity, porosity, expansion, surface tension or similar parameters within Heading No. 90.25. The scope of Heading No. 90.28(4) was treated as covering electrical instruments whose non-electric counterparts fall under Heading No. 90.25, while Heading No. 90.28(1) was regarded as residuary and applicable only if no other specific heading covered the goods.

Conclusion: The bearing analyser BEA-52 was not classifiable under Heading No. 90.28(1) and was correctly classifiable under Heading No. 90.28(4) of the Customs Tariff.

Final Conclusion: The classification adopted by the lower authority was set aside and the refund claim succeeded on the tariff classification issue.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a product is specifically covered by a tariff heading or by the non-electric counterpart provision linked to that heading, it cannot be placed in a residuary entry.

---