Modvat credit under Rule 57D(1) protects waste clearances, but credit on recycled exempt granules remains reversible.

Rule 57D(1) preserves Modvat credit where inputs are contained in waste, refuse or by-product arising during manufacture, so credit is not to be reversed merely because such waste is cleared as waste. The protection does not extend to a distinct recycled product: plastic granules obtained by recycling waste and cleared as exempt goods were treated as separate clearances, and credit attributable to inputs contained in those exempt granules was reversible. Credit remained protected only to the extent the recycled granules were reused in further manufacture. The commentary therefore distinguishes waste cleared as waste from recycled exempt goods for Modvat reversal purposes.

---

---

Issues: (i) Whether Modvat credit on inputs contained in waste cleared as waste was liable to reversal under Rule 57D(1) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944; (ii) Whether Modvat credit on inputs contained in plastic granules obtained by recycling waste and cleared as exempt goods was liable to reversal.

Issue (i): Whether Modvat credit on inputs contained in waste cleared as waste was liable to reversal under Rule 57D(1) of the Central Excise Rules, 1944.

Analysis: Rule 57D(1) protects credit from denial or variation merely because part of the inputs is contained in waste, refuse or by-product arising during manufacture, even where such waste is exempt or chargeable to nil duty. The waste arising in the manufacture of the final product and cleared as waste therefore falls within the protective scope of the rule.

Conclusion: Reversal of Modvat credit on waste cleared as waste was not warranted and the assessee succeeded on this issue.

Issue (ii): Whether Modvat credit on inputs contained in plastic granules obtained by recycling waste and cleared as exempt goods was liable to reversal.

Analysis: Granules obtained after recycling of waste were treated as a separate product and, to the extent they were re-used in manufacture, no reversal arose. However, the granules cleared as exempt goods were not themselves waste within Rule 57D(1). Credit relatable to inputs contained in such recycled granules had therefore to be reversed.

Conclusion: Reversal of Modvat credit was required for the inputs contained in recycled granules cleared under Notification No. 53/88, and the assessee failed on this limited issue.

Final Conclusion: The orders were modified by protecting credit on waste cleared as waste and on recycled granules used again in manufacture, while sustaining reversal only in respect of recycled granules cleared as exempt goods.

Ratio Decidendi: Rule 57D(1) shields credit only for inputs contained in waste, refuse or by-product arising in manufacture, but does not extend to a distinct recycled product cleared as exempt goods; credit attributable to such recycled exempt clearances is reversible.

---