Modvat credit cannot be denied for technical job-work lapses where duty-paid inputs were substantially compliant and used in manufacture.

Modvat credit could not be denied where duty-paid inputs were used in manufacture and only machining was done on axle box castings sent for job work, leaving their identity intact. Rule 57J was inapplicable on the facts, so processing under Rule 57F(2) was not a disqualifying error. The absence of a specific request for direct removal to the job worker, and related gate-pass irregularities, were treated as technical lapses only. Substantial compliance with the credit procedure was sufficient, and a mere procedural irregularity could not defeat admissible credit.

---

---

Issues: Whether Modvat credit could be denied on the ground that axle box castings sent for job work were processed under Rule 57F(2) instead of Rule 57J and that there was non-observance of the prescribed procedure.

Analysis: The dispute turned on whether the goods underwent a transformation attracting Rule 57J or were merely processed castings to which Rule 57F(2) applied. The record showed that only machining was done and the castings retained their identity, making Rule 57J inapplicable. The notice and the order below also proceeded on procedural objections, but the goods were duty paid, were eligible inputs, and were used in the manufacture of final products. The gate passes referred to the job workers and also indicated the appellant's name, and the absence of a specific request for direct removal to the job worker was treated as a technical lapse. Substantial compliance with the law was therefore sufficient, and a mere procedural irregularity could not defeat the credit.

Conclusion: Modvat credit could not be denied for the alleged procedural lapse, and the assessee succeeded.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the substantive conditions for Modvat credit are satisfied and the goods are duty paid inputs used in manufacture, credit cannot be denied merely for non-compliance with a technical or procedural requirement in the job-work process.

---