Customs classification of mixed brass scrap upheld, but redemption fine reduced where no mala fides were shown.

Imported brass keys, brass locks and copper scrap found in a consignment could not be treated as "mixed Brass Scrap Honey" because the goods exceeded the permitted foreign material and did not answer the tariff description of metal waste or scrap not usable as such under the relevant customs note. The confiscation and duty-related classification objection were therefore maintained. However, as the record showed no mala fides and no knowledge of the mix-up on the importer's part, the original redemption fine was found excessive and reduced to a token amount. The substantive adverse findings remained undisturbed, with relief confined to moderation of the fine.

---

---

Issues: Whether brass keys, brass locks and copper scrap found in the consignment could be treated as "mixed Brass Scrap Honey", and whether the redemption fine required modification.

Analysis: The imported goods were found to contain locks, keys and copper scrap in excess of the permitted foreign material, and such items were not covered by the declared description. Chapter Note 6 of Section XIV of the Customs Tariff Act required the goods to be metal waste or scrap not usable as such, which the impugned items were not. The confiscation and duty-related finding therefore disclosed no infirmity. At the same time, the record showed absence of mala fides, and the importer had no knowledge of the mix-up, making the original redemption fine excessive.

Conclusion: The classification objection and confiscation were upheld, but the redemption fine was reduced to a token amount.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded only to the limited extent of reduction of redemption fine, while the substantive adverse findings against the importer remained undisturbed.

Ratio Decidendi: Goods that do not conform to the declared description and are not usable as such within the relevant tariff note are liable to confiscation, though redemption fine may be moderated where mala fides are absent.

---