Deemed Modvat credit on used machinery parts depends on proof that the goods are scrap or re-rollable iron and steel inputs.

Deemed Modvat credit under Rule 57A applies only to specified inputs used in specified final products, and the deemed credit scheme for iron and steel items cannot automatically extend to used machinery parts. Credit is available only if the items are shown to be scrap of iron and steel or re-rollable materials capable of being processed into goods under the relevant tariff headings. Because the factual nature and description of the disputed goods were not properly established, the existing record was insufficient to sustain allowance of credit. The allowance was therefore set aside to that extent and the matter remitted for de novo adjudication on the character of the goods.

---

---

Issues: Whether deemed Modvat credit was admissible on used and worn-out machinery parts claimed to be re-rollable inputs.

Analysis: Modvat credit under Rule 57A is available only for specified inputs used in specified final products, and deemed credit fixed for iron and steel items cannot automatically extend to machinery parts unless it is shown that such items were sold as scrap of iron and steel and were capable of re-rolling into goods falling under Tariff Heading 72 or 73. The factual nature and description of the items were not properly established, and the record did not disclose whether the disputed goods were in fact re-rollable iron and steel structures or merely machinery parts. In the absence of such particulars, the original order allowing credit could not be sustained on the existing material.

Conclusion: Deemed Modvat credit on the machinery parts was not accepted on the record as it stood, and the matter was sent back for fresh consideration after proper examination of the nature of the inputs.

Final Conclusion: The allowance of credit was set aside to that extent and the issue was remitted for de novo adjudication on the factual character of the goods.

Ratio Decidendi: Deemed Modvat credit for iron and steel inputs cannot be extended to used machinery parts unless it is established that the goods are scrap or re-rollable iron and steel materials capable of being processed into goods covered by the relevant tariff headings.

---