Modvat credit excluded from manufacturing cost under Rule 6(b)(ii) on a strong prima facie valuation challenge.

For valuation under Rule 6(b)(ii), Modvat credit on duty-paid inputs was treated as excluded from the cost of manufacture when computing assessable value. The guidance relied on indicated that, where inputs were taken under Modvat and the credit was utilised against duty on the final product, the production cost is reduced to that extent and the credit need not be added back. The matter arose at the stay stage, so the issue was assessed only on a strong prima facie basis, and duty recovery was stayed on execution of a personal bond.

---

---

Issues: Whether, for valuation under Rule 6(b)(ii), the duty paid on inputs taken as Modvat credit was to be included in the cost of manufacture while computing the assessable value.

Analysis: The appeal arose at the stay stage, so the question was only whether a strong prima facie case existed. The proceedings had been initiated under Rule 6 of the Valuation Rules, not under Section 4 of the Act, and the issue was how the cost of manufacture was to be worked out in that framework. The Board guidance and the accounting guidance relied upon indicated that Modvat credit on inputs need not form part of the assessable value. Since the goods were captively consumed and the credit was utilised for duty payment on the final product, the cost of production would stand reduced to the extent of such credit.

Conclusion: The exclusion of Modvat credit from the cost of manufacture was accepted at the prima facie stage, and recovery of duty was stayed on execution of a personal bond.

Ratio Decidendi: For valuation under Rule 6(b)(ii), Modvat credit on duty-paid inputs is not to be included in the cost of manufacture when computing assessable value, at least where a strong prima facie case is made out.

---