Pre-deposit waiver in excise classification dispute granted only partly after balancing prima facie merits and financial hardship.

In a Central Excise classification dispute, the tribunal considered whether the goods fell under Heading 59.06 or Chapter 52, applying the visible impregnation, coating or covering test and noting that final classification required detailed examination of the record. Conflicting chemical opinions and prior departmental orders supported a prima facie case for further scrutiny, while the applicant's financial hardship was also weighed against revenue interests. Full waiver was refused, but partial relief was granted through a directed deposit, with waiver of the balance pre-deposit and stay of recovery subject to compliance.

---

---

Issues: Whether the applicant was entitled to waiver of the balance pre-deposit and stay of recovery pending appeal in a classification dispute under the Central Excise tariff.

Analysis: The dispute turned on whether the goods were classifiable under Heading 59.06 or under Chapter 52, the determinative test being whether the impregnation, coating or covering was visible to the naked eye and whether there was visible layer formation on the surface of the fabric. The materials on record included conflicting chemical opinions and earlier departmental orders supporting a contrary view in similar matters, showing that the issue required detailed examination at final hearing. The financial position of the applicant was also considered, and the record indicated a need to balance hardship against the revenue's interest by imposing a partial deposit.

Conclusion: The applicant was not granted full waiver, but was directed to deposit Rs. 15 lakhs and was granted waiver of the balance pre-deposit and penalty, with stay of recovery subject to compliance.

Final Conclusion: The application was disposed of by granting only partial relief and protecting the applicant from recovery of the balance during the pendency of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi: In a stay or pre-deposit application, where the classification issue is contentious and requires detailed examination, the tribunal may grant partial waiver after balancing prima facie merits and financial hardship.

---