Specific tariff classification governs domestic flour mill components, with goods treated as part of the main machine for duty purposes.

Domestic electric mills with the motor fitted at site were treated as electro-mechanical domestic appliances under sub-heading 85.09 rather than as machinery used in the milling industry under sub-heading 84.37, because the more specific tariff description governed and the cabinets were intended to be treated with the main domestic flour mill for classification purposes. The broader milling-industry entry was held inapplicable, and earlier High Court and Tribunal decisions were distinguished on the basis of different tariff entries and factual settings. The classification under 85.09 was sustained, while Modvat and SSI-related claims were left for consideration by the original authority on remand.

---

---

Issues: Whether domestic electric mills with the motor fitted at site were classifiable under sub-heading 85.09 as electro-mechanical domestic appliances with self-contained electric motor, or under sub-heading 84.37 as machinery used in the milling industry.

Analysis: The tariff entry for sub-heading 85.09 was held to be the more specific description for the goods, since the cabinets were intended for domestic flour mills and were to be treated along with the main machine. The reasoning applied the section note governing classification of parts with machinery and accepted the view that the product was not governed by the broader description of machinery used in the milling industry. The earlier High Court and Tribunal rulings relied upon by the appellants were distinguished on the footing that they dealt with different tariff entries and different factual settings. The classification adopted by the lower authorities was therefore sustained.

Conclusion: The goods were correctly classified under sub-heading 85.09 and the challenge to that classification failed.

Final Conclusion: The duty classification was confirmed against the appellants, while the claims for Modvat and SSI-related benefit were left for the original authority to consider on remand.

Ratio Decidendi: Where a product is used as part of a domestic flour mill and a more specific tariff entry governs its description, classification must follow that specific entry and the goods are to be treated with the main machine for tariff purposes.

---