Tariff classification of laminated paper-based sheets favours residuary entry where paper predominates and trade treats them as non-plastic goods.

Laminated decorative sheets made with paper predominating by weight and resol were treated as paper-based goods rather than plastic sheets for central excise purposes. The Tribunal followed its earlier view that such goods were not known in trade as plastic sheets and therefore did not fall under Item 15A(2) of the erstwhile tariff. On that reasoning, the goods were classified under the residuary Item 68, with consequential relief available to the assessee.

---

---

Issues: Whether laminated decorative sheets manufactured with predominance of paper were classifiable under Item 15A(2) of the erstwhile central excise tariff or under the residuary Item 68.

Analysis: The appeal turned on the proper tariff classification of laminated paper-based sheets. The Tribunal followed its earlier view that laminated sheets manufactured from paper predominating by weight and resol were not known in trade as plastic sheets and, therefore, did not fall within Item 15A(2). No distinguishing facts were shown to warrant departure from that view. The classification under the residuary entry was also consistent with the accepted position urged in the appeal.

Conclusion: The subject goods were held classifiable under Item 68 of the erstwhile central excise tariff and not under Item 15A(2), in favour of the assessee.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded on classification, and the assessee became entitled to the consequential relief available in law.

Ratio Decidendi: Laminated paper-based sheets are to be classified under the residuary tariff item rather than as plastic sheets when paper predominates and the goods are not understood in trade as plastic sheets.

---