Classification of power tiller tyres under the residuary tariff entry was upheld, with reassessment and refund relief granted.

Tyres imported for power tillers were held to fall within the residuary tariff entry for all other tyres, because Item 16-I(1) covered only tyres for motor vehicles or for vehicles and equipment designed for use off the road. The contemporaneous circular issued when the tariff was recast was treated as a useful guide and confirmed that power tiller tyres belonged in the residual category. The contrary classification adopted by the lower authorities was therefore unsustainable, and the assessee was entitled to reassessment and refund relief.

---

---

Issues: Whether tyres imported for power tillers were classifiable under Tariff Item 16-I(1) as tyres for motor vehicles or vehicles and equipment designed for use off the road, or under Tariff Item 16-III as all other tyres for the purpose of countervailing duty.

Analysis: The revised tariff item classified tyres for motor vehicles and for vehicles or equipment designed for use off the road under Item 16-I(1), while Item 16-III covered all other tyres. The contemporaneous circular issued when the tariff was recast expressly stated that power tiller tyres would fall under the residuary category. That clarification was treated as a useful guide to the scope of the tariff entry. On the wording of the item itself, a power tiller is neither a motor vehicle designed for use upon roads nor an off-the-road vehicle or equipment of the kind contemplated by Item 16-I(1). The earlier classification adopted by the lower authorities was therefore not sustainable.

Conclusion: Tyres for power tillers are classifiable under Item 16-III as all other tyres, and the assessee was entitled to reassessment and refund relief.

---