Controlled pricing excludes refundable packing cost from assessable value of Grey Portland Cement under the statutory regime

Under the Cement Control Order and the related government circular, manufacturers were statutorily bound to refund packing material cost and cement prices were fixed by control regime. On that basis, the packing cost was held not to form part of the assessable value of Grey Portland Cement, because it was not an element of the controlled sale price. The tribunal's conclusion followed earlier tribunal and High Court rulings applying the same principle, and the assessee obtained consequential relief.

---

---

Issues: Whether the cost of packing materials was includible in the assessable value of Grey Portland Cement.

Analysis: The assessable value question was examined in the context of the Cement Control Order then in force and the Government circular issued thereunder. The manufacturers were under a statutory obligation to refund the cost of the packing materials, and the price of cement was statutorily fixed. In these circumstances, the packing cost did not form part of the assessable value. The conclusion was also supported by prior tribunal and High Court rulings following the same principle.

Conclusion: The cost of packing materials was not includible in the assessable value of Grey Portland Cement.

Final Conclusion: The appeal succeeded and the impugned order was set aside, with consequential relief to the assessee.

Ratio Decidendi: Where the pricing and refund of packing materials are governed by a statutory control regime creating an obligation to refund the packing cost, such packing cost is not part of the assessable value.

---